Online priest answers questions. Questions to the priest: how to ask

Hello, father! Can you listen to the sacramental prayers on Orthodox channels or do you have to read them yourself? Thank you

Hello. You can listen to prayers, but if possible, it is better to work yourself.

Hello, father! We can't baptize the boy. I don't have a godfather. You cannot baptize without it. So, don’t take your child to church and don’t teach him Christianity... that’s normal... the neighbors have the same situation. No one can baptize. I'm feeling some disappointment towards the church.

Hello. With such a question, it is better to contact the temple you go to or is nearby and tell the priest about your problem. I don’t think that Father won’t offer you a solution to your problem that would suit everyone. God's help.

Hello, is it considered a sin to give birth to a child in marriage from an elderly husband? (60-70 years old). Thank you.

Hello. If you live in a legal marriage, please give birth.

Hello. My dad recently died. February 5th was 9 days since he was gone. I wanted to ask you if it’s possible to occupy yourself with knitting or is it a sin?

Hello. Please, you can knit, it is not a sin.

Thoughts like a river constantly flow through my mind. They arise from the subconscious on their own and why they also disappear without a trace. The brain, while alive, works without stopping, just like the heart, breathing and everything else in the human body. A whole universe, with its own rules and laws.
The river of thoughts that visit me is sometimes not even pleasant. Condemnation, envy, anger, even aggression. I don’t want this, my whole consciousness is against it, but my subconscious constantly slips this nasty stuff in. The result is no friends, difficult relationships with my husband and adult children.
I even managed to condemn my spiritual mentor and stopped visiting the Temple of God.
This made the situation even sadder.
Mentally, I understand everything that the bad things that I attribute to people are in MY head (or heart) and this is the result of my conclusion. If a person, with the help of autosuggestion, can change his inner world, your consciousness and subconscious, how to do this without resorting to outside help???
I don’t want to allow anyone into my inner world, probably for this reason, that split occurred between me and Fr. Sergius. Spiritual people say that after confession they experience a period of purification, lightness and love. For me, everything is completely opposite: after confession, I felt like I was covered in dirt and, worst of all, I was rejected from the church.
I went to confession with a spiritual problem. I am worried about the lack of love, humility, and patience in my soul. But in the end, the confessor was more interested in my bodily sins of a sexual nature. Disgusting and disgusting. He probably enjoys such speeches. Here I am again judging. I can remain silent, but I THINK SO.
Last hope for spiritual healing lost.

First, make peace with your confessor and ask him for forgiveness by telling him about your thoughts. Because with such questions you need to contact a priest and communicate live.

Hello. We have the following situation: the priest, while lighting a 3-story house, pasted an image of a cross only on the 1st floor in the living room, room, hallway and bathtub. And nowhere else... is this right??? I heard that you need to stick them in every room and what should I do now if this is so??

Hello, father did everything right. The crosses are glued in the form of a cross. In the seminary there is a subject in which they study the rites, so there is no need to listen to the “knowledgeable” people who do not have a theological education.

I came to God, like probably many others, out of need... My parents baptized me in infancy, my grandmother talked about God all my childhood, bought me a children's Bible with pictures and thereby taught me. Sometimes I went to church, lit candles for health and peace, prayed in front of the icons as best I could, often in my own words. This was my whole faith. Now I’m 28 years old, I’ve been married for 7 years, we’ve been dreaming of becoming parents for 7 years, but alas...it’s not working out. Once again (rarely) I came to the temple. I stood in front of the icon Mother of God Quick to serve, she begged and cried. A woman who serves in this church came up to me and said that I needed to turn to the priest, saying he would help. Father talked to me, at some point he even calmed me down and said that I needed to consecrate my home and come to confession. I did just that, and from that moment on, I became very interested in all this. I purchased icons for my home, a Psalter with a parallel translation to better understand the meaning of what was written, the Old and New Testaments. Little by little, and whenever possible, I read and get to know each other. I purchased a prayer book for evening and morning prayers, as well as akathists. But at the moment I am in complete confusion... I have been asking the Lord for a child for so long, but nothing changes - that means it is God’s will, but I keep asking... And often I cry in prayer, but if I’m crying - it means I feel sorry for myself (rather, I regret that I won’t have a child, that I won’t be able to play with him, teach him something, go with him to first grade, classes... I have no one to give myself to in life, specifically my maternal part, and in old age who will be my support?!!), and if I feel sorry for myself, it means I don’t agree with the will of God. It turns out vicious circle? I ask him, he doesn’t give, but I still insist, by asking in my prayers. One day a picture came to mind: a small child asks his father for something, and the father, not with malice, but rather with concern for the child, refuses his request, and the child continues to ask, cries and asks. I probably look like that from the outside too... I’m completely confused... I know that you can’t beg for something or someone. But all the same, even if secretly, if not with words, but with my heart I ask God for a child. What should I do? Are my requests in prayer an expression of disagreement with the will of God? Maybe I should be humble and never even think about it again? But I can’t... When I think about the child, I cry, I feel very sad and scared, but isn’t this despondency and grumbling about my life? Tell me, please, what to do?
I think this topic will be of interest to many, because deep down in our souls each of us has a cherished desire for which we ask God. But we don’t always receive an answer to our prayers in the form of the fulfillment of our desires, so how should we approach this? Continue to ask and pray, in the hope that one day God will give us what we ask for. Or is it still worth coming to terms with the fact that since God didn’t give it, he won’t give it anymore, and for the rest of your life restrain your impulse to ask for what you want within strict limits.
Please forgive me for writing it long and chaotically, but I think I got the main idea across. Thank you in advance.

“Ask, and it will be given to you; seek, and you will find; knock, and it will be opened to you; for everyone who asks receives...” (Matthew 7:7,8). Such thoughts should not be allowed, because the Lord, as a loving Father, provides everything necessary for the salvation of the soul, and not by fulfilling the passionate impulses of the soul. Calm down and humble yourself under the strong hand of God. And in due time the Lord will give you what you ask for. You are only 28 years old. God help you.

Hello. I like to embroider with beads, landscapes, icons, but I don’t know when it’s possible and when it’s not, and what prayer to read at the beginning and end of the work? Thanks in advance for your answer!

Hello. In church, in order to do something you need to take the blessing of a priest or bishop. The same goes for writing icons or embroidering them. Pious icon painters fasted before work and read an akathist to the person whose image they were going to depict.

Hello. This question worries me: when my husband and I quarrel, I begin to dream about another man, imagine how my life would turn out with another, and have erotic fantasies. The marriage has been completed. What is the correct name for this sin? What should you call him in confession? Adultery? So this is like physical betrayal, but it has not happened and will not happen. Thanks for the answer.

Hello. This sin is called adultery. “Whoever looks at a woman lustfully has already committed adultery with her in his heart” (Matthew 5:28).

Hello! This is nonsense, but as a person of little faith, this is unpleasant for me. There is an inscription from the ceiling of the temple of Takht-i-Sulaiman (Throne of Solomon) at Dal Lake in Srinagar, which says: “The columns were created by Bihishti Zargar, in the year 54. Khwaja Rukun, son of Murjan, built these columns. At this time Yuz Asaf declared about his prophetic mission, in the year 54. He is Jesus, the prophet of the children of Israel." References to legends of the traveling Jesus also survive in medieval Islamic chronicles. The 15th century book Rauzat as-safa, which describes the lives of kings and prophets, mentions him in the following words: “He was a great traveler. From his country he came with several disciples to Nasibain. And he sent them into the city so that they could teach." The second part of the theory of Jesus' stay in India is connected with the period of the so-called missing years of his life, when, according to the writings of St. Luke, "Jesus gained wisdom" (although the Gospel does not indicate where and how). In 1887, during a trip to the Himalayan Ladakh, called "little Tibet", Nikolai Notovich (1858-?), a Russian journalist, officer and explorer, learned some details. In the monastery of Himis, he came across a manuscript about the life of Saint Issa, who seemed surprisingly similar to Jesus. No less controversial topic and subject of search by Yuz Asaf. He went to look for the descendants of the so-called 10 lost tribes of Israel. They disappeared from the map when their country was occupied by the Assyrians. There are indeed ethnic groups and communities in the Middle East and Indian Peninsula whose traditions date back to the history of the lost tribes. The best known are the Afghan Pashtuns and Bnei Israel, a community of Hindus who recognize themselves as descendants of Israelis. Despite years of isolation, numerous Jewish traditions were preserved. In the spring of 1925, during his Central Asian expedition, N.K. Roerich visited Kashmir, where he wrote down that the legend of the presence of Christ was widespread in India and beyond. The Master's tomb is located in the basement of a private house in Srinagar. The existence of an inscription is indicated that the son of Joseph lies here; healings seemed to take place at the tomb and the smell of aromas spread. N.K. Roerich also quoted lines from a Kashmiri song about Christ. Or maybe Jesus actually survived the crucifixion and fled to a country where he could count on a warmer reception than in his homeland? I ask these questions to believe in Christ, and not to rant about whether Jesus was in India or not.

Hello. First, read “The Law of God” as edited by Archpriest Seraphim Slobodskov. God's help.

Question No. 18160 (Miscellaneous)
Hello, I am an Internet marketer and have 3 years of practical experience. I am looking for a permanent remote job as an internet marketer/brand manager. What I can do: - Administer websites on CMS Bitrix/Wp/OpenCart/Joomla/Tilda/Lpmotor/uKit/uCoz - SEO website optimization - competitor analysis, semantics collection, query clustering, writing technical specifications for copywriters/ generating relevant meta tags for pages . I use modern tools + Key Collector - Set up and maintain advertising companies in Yandex.Direct - intern payment systems + telephony + RoiStat - Create maps of meaning (mide map), - Collect conversion Landing Pages - Create technical specifications for programmers, designers, layout designers, copyrights... For all suggestions, write to my personal email: [email protected] (Internet marketer (РњРѕСЃРєРІР°), 03/14/2019 11:57)

Question No. 18159 (Spiritual life)
Hello! It's started now Lent and at Sunday service the priest invited all parishioners to come to Communion in the first week of Lent. I really wanted to do this, but just these days I will be in uncleanness. Is it possible for a woman to receive communion these days or not? There, after all, you will still have to venerate the Bible and the cross during confession. (Irina (Kyiv), 03/14/2019 11:08)

Question No. 18158 (Miscellaneous)
Good afternoon, father. Bless. I began to catch myself thinking that I was afraid to pray for deliverance from passions and sins. The thought popped into my head that what if God would take me and deliver me from this with the help of some kind of sorrow. It turns out that I am begging for punishment for myself. What is this, distrust of God? How can I get rid of such thoughts and do I need to confess this? I don’t know if you can understand me. Maybe I didn’t formulate the question correctly, but I’m still grateful in advance. (Elena (Vinnitsa), 03/14/2019 11:00)

Question No. 18157 (Miscellaneous)
Hello! Last night, before going to bed, I watched documentaries about elders and saints. I have been carrying an icon of St. with me for several days. LUKI Krymsky and before going to bed I put it next to me (I have back pain, so I carry it with me), questions about solving problems and getting rid of back pain were spinning in my thoughts! And so I fell asleep, woke up at 4 in the morning after “sleep paralysis”, where I tried to call my wife, but I could only moo, my cat looked at all this in fear, when I finally woke up, I realized that I was lying with my back to the icon of St. Luke, How can one evaluate such an incomprehensible feeling? This is not the first time this has happened to me. Thank you! (Pavel, 03/14/2019 10:51)

Question No. 18156 (Man. Woman. Family. Children.)
((РњРѕСЃРєРІР°), 03/14/2019 01:39)

Question No. 18136 (Miscellaneous)
Hello, Father Alexander! With all my heart I congratulate you and your entire parish on the beginning of Great Lent! With the beginning of the Holy Pentecost! I wish you peace and tranquility, mental and physical purity! Fasting that is beneficial for the soul! God bless you! (Irina (Kursk), 03/11/2019 08:08)

Question No. 18130

You wrote here that your mother “cannot believe as the Orthodox Church demands.” And I tell you that the Orthodox Church does not demand anything from anyone, it simply warns - do not jump from the fifth floor, it will hurt. You have only reached the first floor, but you are already thinking that you will have to jump, and you are trying to shudder from the pain in advance, forgetting that you may not have to jump, maybe stop.
Why do you go to Church? Because you're afraid? Looking at yourself and measuring everyone to your own yardstick? And we go to the temple because we believe in God, who said: “Him that comes to me I will never cast out” (John 6.37) And where is your faith?
I began to notice that many people now think for everyone else, and not just think, but try to live for others. And it turns out as in the old saying - there is neither a horse nor a cart yet, but they have already harnessed it and rode off. Here you are, driving so hard that you are flying past life, and what you are afraid of is what you will get in the end. But this can be avoided.

I don’t know if you’ll see yourself in this, but it’s written about this too:
Some Cook, literate,
He ran from the kitchen
To the tavern (he ruled the pious
And on this day the godfather held a funeral feast),
And at home, keep food away from mice
I left the cat.
But what does he see when he returns? On the floor
Pie scraps; and Vaska the Cat is in the corner,
Crouching for a barrel of vinegar,
Purring and grumbling, he works on the little chicken.
"Oh, you glutton! Oh, you villain! -
Here the Cook reproaches Vaska: -
Aren't you ashamed of the walls, not just the people?
(But Vaska still cleans up the little chicken.)
How! Having been an honest Cat until now,
Sometimes people say that you are an example of humility, -
And you... what a shame!
Now all the neighbors will say:
"Vaska the cat is a rogue! Vaska the cat is a thief!
And Vaska didn’t just go to the cookhouse,
There is no need to let him into the yard,
Like a greedy wolf into a sheepfold:
He is corruption, he is a plague, he is a plague of these places!
And Vaska listens and eats.)
Here is my rhetorician, giving free rein to his words,
There was no end to the moralizing.
But what? While he was singing it,
Vaska the cat ate all the roast.
And I would tell another cook to write on the wall:
So as not to waste speeches there,
Where should power be used?

How similar it is! Smoking another menthol cigarette, sit and think, now all the demons will tell you not to let her into the Kingdom of Heaven... Here you suffer, and there still...

Now we have a Week about the paralytic, that is, about the one who cannot do anything himself because he has no strength. Twice in the Gospels the Lord heals the paralytic, one was brought by four, the other at the Sheep's font. And he heals both by simple forgiveness of sins. Immediately, strength appears in the relaxed. Here we are too. After Confession, I would use the power over myself and not allow myself to do such things. Believe me, we have the strength to do this! But, instead, we again start persuading ourselves, or even again, we do the same thing. But even if you haven’t seen these powers, go to Communion and ask the Lord for strength, to take power over yourself and no longer sin by relaxing your mind. You just have to live!

It often happens to us
And work and wisdom to see there,
Where you just have to guess
Just get down to business.
A Casket was brought to someone from the master.
The decoration and cleanliness of the Casket caught my eye;
Well, everyone admired the beautiful Casket.
Here a sage enters the mechanics room.
Looking at the Casket, he said: “A casket with a secret,
So; it doesn't even have a lock;
And I undertake to open it; yes, yes, I'm sure of it;
Don't laugh so secretly!
I will find the secret and I will reveal the little chest to you:
In mechanics, I’m also worth something.”
So he set to work on the Casket:
Turns him from all sides
And he breaks his head;
First a carnation, then another, then a bracket.
Here, looking at him, another
Shakes his head;
They whisper, and they laugh among themselves.
It just rings in my ears:
"Not here, not like that, not there!"
The mechanic is even more eager.
Sweated, sweated; but finally tired
I fell behind Chest
And I couldn’t figure out how to open it;
And the casket simply opened.

Our body was formed in the womb, with which we will go through life. Here, living on earth, we ourselves form the soul. That is, we dress her in clothes, either in: “adultery, fornication, uncleanness, lasciviousness, idolatry, sorcery, enmity, quarrels, envy, anger, strife, disagreements, [temptations,] heresies, hatred, murder, drunkenness, disorderly conduct, etc. like" (Gal. 5.19-21), or in: "love, joy, peace, long-suffering, kindness, goodness, faith, meekness, self-control" (Gal. 5.22-23) Or in other words, so that, living in relaxation, leave from life, because the first clothes are acquired easily, just don’t resist anything, and you will be like that. But such a person will no longer see the Kingdom of Heaven. Or, having made every effort on yourself, put on second clothes, and then you will have something to cover your shame in the same ordeals, not to mention the Kingdom of Heaven. Everything is very simple and you don’t need to invent anything!

04.05.15 Mon 15:11 - Anonymous

Polina Appolinaria

Oh, in vain, father, you think that I live in a relaxed mind. On the contrary, she is focused, she has changed a lot, a lot. I will never enter into a relationship with a man again, no matter how much I would like to (Thank God and I don’t need this due to a painful condition, which is not relaxation of the body and mind, it’s just my once precious health “planted”), I will not cultivate envy and love of money, despite poverty, I will not feel sorry for myself (as Elena writes, she saw self-pity, and this is something else, really), I always pray when I see temptations (the closest prayer is “May God rise again...”, i.e. the prayer to the Cross, the Lord’s Prayer itself, I sincerely repent not just of some individual sins, but of my entire life, for which I really want to cry, not out of self-pity, as Elena writes, but out of repentance, simply because that you really want to turn back time and change everything, but the fact that this cannot be done is painful). Father Vladimir from the village of Glebychevo near Primorsk says that there is no need to think and say this way, because the invaluable experience that you now have cannot be acquired in any other way, the way of the righteous and without mistakes. I feel that he is right, I need to let go of past sins in life, which I will consciously never repeat, because I repented sincerely, very sincerely, for example: in adultery, blasphemy, condemnation, abortion (I listened to my mother, a fool, but with responsibility I’m not filming myself and I hope that at these damned ordeals they won’t show me murdered children, because at that time I didn’t perceive abortion as murder, because for me then a person was “from birth”, but not in a cellular state); now everything is different: I refused by force of will antidepressants and sleeping pills, but I continue to take painkillers, which are similar to sleeping pills, simply because the dream is very strange and scary, my back hurts; I can’t yet overcome the fear of hell, it’s true, I see it everywhere, for example, in Yulia Voznesenskaya’s book “My Posthumous Adventures” everything is described so colorfully that I go to work, do something, but can’t think about almost anything else Can. Forgive me for my frankness, I put everything on display on the general website, but somehow I don’t know how to do it any other way. Tell me anyway: will a person’s good deeds be counted there, in another world, despite the fact that he did not have time to take communion? How to overcome fear and despair by reading literature about ordeals, even if prayer helps short time, but does not completely banish fear? Why is smoking considered a sin (this has nothing to do with me, there are generally different opinions on this matter), because even Andrei Kuraev “is not a sin, but rather a sinful habit”? Can the Lord have mercy if passions negative emotions nevertheless, they will not be defeated, it will not be possible to eradicate them completely, because sometimes negative emotions and the passion of anger arise precisely as a reaction to injustice, for me - a reaction to obvious indifference? What to do if a divorce is necessary (I feel this more than I even know), but we have a child whom I will not raise either financially or in any way at all, because I don’t have the health or basic human strength to do this, or you can simply rely on God and go take the divorce papers without fear of anything? Thank you for the comparison with the cook in your parable and for the balcony, “from which you may not have to jump...”

04.05.15 Mon 22:00 - Priest Sergius

This parable is not mine, but grandfather Krylov’s “The Cat and the Cook”

I love reading Krylov, not only his fables, but also his early works, how subtly and accurately he conveys the similarity of our actions.
The main tactic of demons is to divide and conquer. Therefore, when you act to destroy relationships with people, then, most likely, demons persuaded you to do this. So you are already starting to put walls between you and the people around you. I beg you not to do this, the farther you are from people, the further you are from God, almost all the Holy Fathers say. Remember that even such a weak person, you are needed, first of all, by your child, who will no longer have another father. God needs you, why then did He go to the Cross so that you would slowly drag yourself to suicide? I ask again: where is your faith? There is not a word about it, but it turns out that you read all sorts of books of dubious origin, some Orthodox fantasy and draw your conclusions from these works, and not from the Gospel. Here you can dream of anything, not just the fear of ordeal. Is Yulia Voznesenskaya a saint? glorified by the Church? that you take all her words on faith? Either there will be something similar, or not, it’s written on the water with a pitchfork, and you are already waving like a flag: “Ah. It says there...” I do not advise you to read such works, especially about ordeals. Teach yourself not to dwell on these thoughts. Start reading the Gospel better, Apostle, every day, at least by chapter, but constantly. I think it won’t be long until you finally get over yourself.

About smoking. One day at Rev. John of Kronstadt was asked: “Father, is smoking a sin?” - he replied: “Whether it’s a sin or not, I don’t know, but they smell like a goat.” There are many mansions in hell, there is a fiery Gehenna, there is a student of decay, there is the darkness of eternal darkness, there are also smoky barracks... Do you want to sit in a smoking room for eternity? After all, we are used to “calming” ourselves with a cigarette or two. So you will “calm down” yourself forever. Smoking, it’s the same sinful captivity as any other, every cigarette is taken by the collar and dragged, let’s go, and the person goes, because he’s in captivity and doesn’t even want to break out. You should not reassure yourself that this is not a sin, but a sinful habit. Although it is a habit, it is a sinful one.

And one more property of sin - sin loves darkness, loves that others do not see it, because it loses its power when it is seen, when it is in the light. He cannot, in this case, act freely. That’s why I refused to correspond in personal mail and stayed on the site, sorry if I caused any inconvenience. Continue to Confess and take Communion. Once, when I had just come to faith, I went for a lecture. I realized that every disease is demons, so I think I’ll kick him out and live normally. I have ankylosing spondylitis, they say it is incurable. There are a lot of people, and during the reading of the Gospel everyone usually kneels. I’m on my knees on the second day, and in my head Someone asks: “What are you doing here?” I was dumbfounded, wow, is that what I’m thinking to myself? and the Voice continues: “Do you go to Church? Do you confess? Do you take communion? So what else do you need?” Then I realized that I would not have any healing, I had to humble myself. And indeed, a little later I read from the Apostle Paul: “And so that I would not become proud of the extraordinary revelations, a thorn was given to me in the flesh, the angel of Satan, to oppress me so that I would not become proud. Three times I prayed to the Lord to remove him from me. But The Lord said to me: “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness.” , in oppression for Christ, for when I am weak, then I am strong" (2 Cor. 12.7-10) And after I became a priest, we had an accident in a car, and now I have been walking bent for seventeen years. And, you know, nothing! It doesn't even bother me!

So I ask you, do not despair, but believe in God, He knows how to protect us!

05/08/15 Fri 14:08 - Anonymous

Appolinaria

1. I also love Krylov, although I forgot this fable “The Cat and the Cook” from school, but when I said “Your parable,” I did not mean, of course, “Your personal one.” It is clear that this fable is very instructive, although, I must admit, it is very offensive to me.
2. You say: what Voznesenskaya writes about the ordeals is “written on water with a pitchfork...” But your phrase “there are many mansions in hell, there is a fiery Gehenna, there is a student of corruption, there is the darkness of eternal darkness, there are smoky barracks.. ." - from St. Scriptures? I just can’t remember the phrase about the smoky barracks. It’s hard to comprehend that a smoking person, even with a kind heart (again, I don’t mean myself, almost all my relatives smoke, and I don’t have a “nicotine” addiction, Thank God) can so easily be cast into hell . What is this, a revelation of the church? And why does Voznesenskaya write “with a pitchfork on the water”, and the blzh. Theodora, A. Optinsky, the book “On the Exodus of the Soul...” and other sources - not “with a pitchfork on the water”, because many describe ordeals... Is it only because Voznesenskaya is a “Christian fantasy”? After all, she actually repeats what respected people of Orthodoxy write, only, I would say, in a more soft form. When you listen to St. Oleg Stenyaev, for example, becomes not just ill, but very ill, because 20 ordeals are not a joke, it is torture for the soul. And no one, There, in another world, will ask: why did you do this (for example, you stole when you had no choice at the moment, because of hunger, etc. or borrowed money and did not pay it back on time - also theft?!), I just acted badly - there is no excuse for this, no matter what the reason. Here, of course, I already have myself in mind: I took money without asking my husband, because I knew that he wouldn’t give it, no matter how I asked, because he doesn’t know what an attack is (I wouldn’t want to talk about an attack, but, believe me, this is a very scary thing), and the doctor cannot write out a preferential prescription, and, unfortunately, the medicine is not vital according to the legislation of the Russian Federation (as for diabetics).
3. I also stole money from my grandfather for the same reason, realizing that I would not be able to repay the debt in full, only in parts. All this is not because I don’t want to work, but because the salary is simply not enough, I’m working for now, but I can’t get another job that pays well. So tell me: what should I do? Maybe there is a relief fund for people like me, who are not disabled, because they won’t give you disability anyway, but not quite full-fledged people, whose ailments and pain do not allow them to work normally, and are known only to a tiny percentage of people, so as not to fall into the sins of theft or the like, because, I’m afraid, I won’t be able to repay the debts or I won’t repay the entire amount, although I willingly forgive, it’s easier for me, it’s not a merit, or rather not my merit, but from God.
4. Tell me why divorce is certainly “from demons”? For many years I have not been able to find a common language with my husband. After all, it is obvious that it is simpler and easier for him in all respects to condemn me, to say: “you are pretending to justify your laziness,” but in fact, he simply feels sorry for my money, and this greed towards me does not allow me to completely reconcile With his position, I’m not even saying that he can easily humiliate me in front of the child, and I “stupidly” don’t know how to prevent this? Is such a life with a person who, of course, does not love, although he is a magnificent, wonderful father to my child, or rather children, does not respect and does not regret (a synonym for love) - not a path to a heart attack, not destruction? I realize that during a divorce it will be difficult financially, probably unbearable, and I will not be able to support the children myself, but I really hope that they will not starve and the Lord will help, no...? To hope for peace where there is none and never will be, can one only endure it and not provoke the husband to either bad or good?

05/08/15 Fri 15:49 - Priest Sergius

“Whoever commits sin is a slave of sin” (John 8.34)

So, if you cannot calm yourself down and put yourself to sleep without 1-2 menthol cigarettes (your words), and even without pills, then you are precisely the slave of those menthol cigarettes. Imagine, you got to the Kingdom of Heaven, and there are no smoking rooms there, but you are already accustomed to these menthol cigarettes, you can no longer live without them, you will have to look for a smoking room. And they are only in hell. You will enter there yourself, but you will no longer be able to leave, because you are a slave. Indeed, the Holy Scriptures do not mention smoky barracks, but a woman who had an accident and died spoke about them... and then was resurrected, and after some time, remembering everything, began to tell. This can be believed, because God is Love, and He does not take away a person’s free will; if a person likes to smoke, then he will be given such an opportunity.
Blessed Theodora wrote about her experiences, Rev. Ambrose of Optina spoke about what was revealed to him, and almost all Orthodox sources confirm their thoughts in the words of other authors. This is done in order to explain that they are not the only ones who say this, that is, they speak in a new way, but do not say anything new. Yulia Voznesenskaya writes, without referring to anyone, ordinary stories, richly seasoned with fantasies and all kinds of horror stories. In any case, when reading these books, I got this impression, and under no circumstances will I refer to her fantasies.

Do you see how cunning you are? You allow yourself to forgive other people’s debts to you, but you do not allow other people the opportunity to forgive you your debts. And by carefully trying to hide this sin of yours, you are ruining yourself. I wonder if you even repented of this? You seem to know the Scripture.

I have already written to you that the tactics of demons are all kinds of divisions. And this division comes from you, because you do not say that your husband wants to divorce you.

Now I have questions for you: 1. How often do you go to church? 2. Do you go to the same temple? 3. How often do you go to Confession and Communion? 4. Aren't you afraid of Confession? 5. What prayers do you read at home? 6. Do you confess to the same priest?

05/09/15 Sat 14:27 - Anonymous

Appolinaria

Now I can’t find your questions, or your letter in general, so, from memory, I’m writing confusingly and illogically, sorry (a virus in the computer, the lines “run away” from me):
1. I try to go to church every Sunday, but it doesn’t always work out. If I don’t go to church, I try to get to “church on the screen,” on TV, on the Soyuz channel, and repeat some prayers with the priest. Throughout my life I go to different churches, there are many of them in St. Petersburg, but I only go to receive communion in one (wooden Orthodox church in the village of Glebychevo, Leningrad region) relatively recently, because I trust Father Vladimir, he had my most complete confession, many hours. I consider her the main thing in life, and one can only be amazed at how he put up with me then and still puts up with me. True, I am infinitely sorry that there is no financial opportunity to travel to see him often.
2. You called me cunning, so my husband says so, he also says that I am lazy and arrogant (it’s understandable with him, it’s easier for him to think so as not to give money for treatment, this is obvious), well, God bless him, apparently so it is, but reading this in your letter, I honestly admit, it becomes very offensive, because I try as best I can (since I came to faith) not to lie, not to be cunning and not to get out. Apparently I’m trying in vain. And with my grandfather the situation is like this (for me it’s complicated and incomprehensible in the sense of what to do?): he’s very old, I’ve been looking for an approach to him for a long time, all my life, but I tried poorly, he’s too difficult a person, he allowed himself, as it seems to me, unacceptable insults, hatred towards me and such statements that, honestly, the desire to go to him and help him even in memory of my father (grandfather is the father of my deceased dad) disappears completely. And now telling him that I take his money for medicine, nothing else, is completely useless. He is, how can I put it, not entirely adequate. It seems to him that I am stealing money from the apartment, from a briefcase, a mattress, my husband is stealing, my sister is stealing, they are stealing everything, in a word. Sister, house help, me - everything was stolen by some large amounts, his savings. I can’t imagine how I’ll come to him to repent of taking money for medicine? He will not forgive not because he does not know how to forgive, but simply the reaction may not be adequate. Yeah, that means you did take money from your briefcase, etc.! Thief, etc.! I'm honestly not ready for such a turn yet. Yes, I’m cowardly, yes, I’m weak, but I can’t help it. I cannot learn, even with God’s help (after all, He gave me such a grandfather; other, beloved relatives died) to forgive and endure insults. They say that to be offended is a reflexive verb with a reflexive suffix, i.e. It's impossible to be offended if you don't want to. But I still think that it is possible to be offended, and very strongly, when you have been insulted, specifically offended consciously or even unknowingly. And if a person is alive, reacting, made of nerves, flesh and blood, and also with a rather weak, frankly speaking, psyche, like Ivan Gromov in Chekhov’s “Ward No. 6,” you can react with indignation, indignation. Although, Glory to you, Lord, it is GIVEN to me to be indignant, yes, it is given, not for long, not at all, it is easier and more organic for me to forgive and let go of the offense than to keep it to myself, although there are things that I remember for a long time. This doesn’t mean that I hold a grudge, I just remember that with this person you can’t do this and that, you can only use certain methods. I want to escape. It’s easier for me now (I’m going to see him) to allocate a certain amount from my salary and give it to food, and then pay it back until I cover at least 30,000 (this is very approximate). If all of the above is a trick, then how to live, not to be cunning, never to lie? In the world this is almost impossible. It’s also a shame that with you I’m being sincere and not being cunning. Well, okay, you know better. It’s easier for me and my mother to lie, for example, by praising a tasteless salad (which happens extremely rarely), than to say directly: I can’t eat, I can’t eat it. She will be offended, and so much so that I, I myself will be completely exhausted later, why, they say, did I offend?
3. Yulia Voznesenskaya writes stories, but I mean a book that, although called “fantasy,” is not at all like fiction. The book-parable “My Posthumous Adventures” is about how the heroine (Voznesenskaya herself) fell into a deep coma, i.e. died, and the body was supported in Munich with wires and devices. This is some kind of instructive post-mortem experience, but I don’t understand how this differs from BLZ. Theodora, can you trust that woman who had an accident that it wasn’t “a pitchfork through the water”? By the way, I listened to her story.
4. You need to quit smoking, you can’t use drugs, drinking is harmful, you can’t overeat, there is no excuse for this, but why will these people certainly die? If they have a good soul, I can’t understand. They don’t force other people to smoke and drink. I don’t mean alcoholics and drug addicts, who don’t care where to get the hellish potion, they won’t spare their mother, I mean people who don’t abuse all this (except for drugs, of course). We all, except the monks, are made up of passions and habits, will it all follow us and “there”? I have a stupid habit of waving a piece of paper when I write and say something or twirling a flag. This may even irritate many people, but is it really necessary to get rid of it? Sometimes it happens involuntarily.
5. Yes, my husband doesn’t want to get a divorce, but seeing what I am like, why and by what right does he mold me into an ideal? Moreover, he sees that I do not correspond to him, and... a conflict arises. What makes him angry? If, due to back pain, I, however, cannot clean the apartment as before (I mopped the floors 5 times a day), I cannot do general cleaning, I cannot get up at 6 in the morning, I often get colds and have a diagnosis - is it possible? is this a reason to “spread rot” on me like this, to say that I’m lazy, etc.?
6. Despotism is not a reason for divorce, because it is a demonic principle? Vladimir told me that Christian marriage is a free marriage, unlike Islam, but where is the freedom? A despot husband who is also an atheist, won’t this lead to trouble? I myself do not have such faith that I am ready to endure everything and lead him, the unfortunate one, to Orthodoxy...

05/09/15 Sat 19:59 - Priest Sergius

Say, my questions were not found, nothing, I will repeat:

1. How often do you go to church? 2. Do you go to the same temple? 3. How often do you go to Confession and Communion? 4. Aren't you afraid of Confession? 5. What prayers do you read at home? 6. Do you confess to the same priest?
I would really like to receive not vague answers, but precise ones. And yet, I didn’t say that you were being cunning with me, excuse me, you’ve already thought of that.

Nevertheless, having not yet received answers, I will try once again to remind you: “everyone who commits sin is a slave of sin” (John 8.34)
“Sin committed gives birth to death” (James 1.15)
“Whoever commits sin also commits lawlessness; and sin is lawlessness” (1 John 3.4)
“Whoever commits sin is of the devil, because the devil sinned first” (1 John 3.8)
“We know...he who is born of God keeps himself, and the evil one does not touch him” (1 John 5.18).

But your points 4 and 5, to be honest, completely discouraged me. I'm starting to doubt whether you are Orthodox? In the morning I was thinking, what is the seventh question I should ask, an important one. Only now he has appeared: what do you actually want to hear from me? This is my last question.

10.05.15 Sun 14:10 - Anonymous

Appolinaria

1. I go to different temples, there are many of them in St. Petersburg: approximately, on average, once every 2 weeks, sometimes more often, sometimes less often, this is the average figure. I try to come in whenever possible. On Sundays I read the Akathist to the Mother of God, but it doesn’t happen every Sunday; more often it’s for health reasons, and not because I don’t like the Orthodox Church. I wrote about this earlier (maybe more briefly), and I don’t understand why the answers are “blurry”?
2. Unfortunately, I do not receive Holy Communion often, but once a year it is mandatory, and only with Father Vladimir. Previously, this was the case with different priests. True, very soon I’m going to go to Glebychevo again, as soon as the financial opportunity arises. Sorry, now I don’t understand, why does this even matter? Is it necessary to receive communion and confess to different priests? After all, I already wrote that Father Vladimir is the only one I trust, who knows me, and to whom I can ask any question and tell him what I’m embarrassed to tell. to a loved one and I don’t want to tell another priest. Yes, I understand, this is false shame, I can only write, it’s easier for me, but I can’t say it out loud in detail, and I’m not able to remember everything... This concerns mainly my past.
3. Am I afraid of confession? Good question! Yes and no. On the one hand there is fear, on the other hand there is relief. I used to be very afraid, but now I’m less afraid. But now I don’t fall into those sins that I repented of several times in different churches when I didn’t yet know Father Vladimir. Fornication, abortion, unbelief, blasphemy against God, harmfulness, envy, in a word, NOT CHRISTIAN LIFE. Now I have a question: is it necessary to repeat this at every confession, and remembering something else in detail, for example, various fornications in youth, should I also tell this in detail or is it enough to characterize it in one word, for example - adultery? Or: anger often arises at children when they are mischievous and disobey. Is it possible to say in confession: “anger” and not go into details: at whom is the anger, why is it angry, anger at a cat that pees in the bed, etc.? I keep asking this in order to know: how to quickly and clearly confess to any priest, given the flow of people, if Father Vladimir, who usually asks leading questions himself and makes confession easier for me in this sense, cannot confess and give me communion due to distance distances?
4. At home I read “Our Father”, a prayer to the Cross, “Virgin Mother of God, rejoice (sing)”, “Lord, forgive and have mercy on me, a sinner”, simply “Lord, have mercy”. The prayer “Creed” doesn’t work at all. Again, I don’t understand: is this so important? Andrei Tkachev generally said that the “Our Father” prayer is from the Lord himself, everyone always needs it, but in principle there can be only one prayer, the main thing is that it lies on the heart and is from the heart, extremely sincere, not “on a piece of paper” , but from the heart. This is not an exact quote. I don't remember exactly. Is he wrong? If I’m wrong, who, excuse me, should I believe? We are earthly people, worldly people, we don’t know anything.
5. What discouraged you and why do you have doubts about Orthodox faith? I don't understand at all, sorry for my stupidity. Point 4: apparently I want to justify people’s habits. No, I don’t justify it; Who am I to judge and justify?, I’m just asking: we are all made up of habits, does this mean hell after death if a person has a good heart? A person has not had time to quit smoking, does this mean that he will go to the same smoking room and barracks that you wrote about or is it actually not for us to judge? I myself think that it is not for us to judge, but I still ask you to answer, I need to hear your opinion. Or do you think that a person’s heart cannot be good if he smokes? It is clear that smoking, alcohol and drugs are more than a habit, although Kuraev writes about smoking precisely as a habit, but I meant habits (point 4, apparently the letter disappeared again) such as: waving a piece of paper, a bookmark, a pen during a conversation; the habit of talking to oneself, etc.: it seems like nothing bad, but it can annoy the interlocutor. Sorry, if the questions seem idiotic to you, you don’t have to answer. In point 5, I also didn’t understand what actually discouraged you? Can divorce be considered a sin if... And then I already wrote about how my husband treats me, why should I live with a despot if I don’t have the faith that will save my husband? Or rather, there is no faith, but rather there is no hope that he will come to faith and treat his own wife a little better. “With a believing wife, the husband is saved” (inaccurate quote). That's what I meant. Is it worth enduring everything just because you are Orthodox, even the unacceptable, such as beatings? After all, they treat us the way we allow. What should I do if I don’t feel the strength to endure and save, and I don’t know how not to allow myself to be treated poorly? Does this mean that I am not an Orthodox person? So you doubt that I am a believer? Once again I apologize for the stupidity and misunderstanding.
6. I only want to hear from you answers to questions, even stupid ones. If I ask, it means I need it.
7. Can what I wrote to you and put on public display for several days, starting on May 2, be considered a confession? Or is this just a conversation?
8. If you do not answer this letter, I will understand that gaining at least some understanding is a pointless waste of time, which is already short, and I will not bother you with my stupid questions.
Apolinaria, Polina in the world.

01/08/18 Mon 23:25 - Russian wanderer

The Russian Wanderer answers

Dear Gregory! Merry Christmas!

It’s even strange that in 6 years you have not come across the knowledge of the Church about the Invoking Grace of our Lord Jesus Christ. It was She who acted in you for a whole year, She filled you and worked miracles.

And you don’t know about the next period of a Christian's life- as if "Forsakenness", about the period of impoverishment of faith. This is how it happens that God hides His help for a while and tests a person’s DETERMINATION to follow His path already in the conditions of ordinary human life. Where is waiting for those good seeds that were sown by His Grace to germinate and grow.

The saint of the 20th century, the Monk Joseph the Hesychast, knew all this well and is talking about exactly this.

Father Anatoly Garmaev has an excellent large book “WAYS AND MISTAKES OF NOVICES ANSWERS TO QUESTIONS (CONVERSATIONS ON A PILGRIMAGE VOYAGE)”
(http://zavet.ru/garmaev/ways.htm#01), describing in detail all the main periods of Christian life IN ORTHODOXY.

People also have a different format of religious life - only human, without the wonderful period of action of the Invoking Grace of the Holy Spirit. There are quite a few such people and they do not understand how it is to LIVE in the GRACE of Jesus Christ.

You, thank God, know! Therefore, read the book of Father Anatoly, and calmly, without despondency, continue your path to God.

01/29/18 Mon 23:23 - Archpriest Anatoly Garmaev

Answered by the priest of the Russian Orthodox Church MP Archpriest Anatoly (Garmaev)

Dear Gregory! Perhaps to chagrin, but through it – for consolation, I am writing you an answer.

You write: For six years now “there has been no joy, abandonment by God, prayer is given with difficulty and carelessness.”
This is despite the fact that, being, it seems, a truly searching and persistent person, you turn to priests, search on the Internet, fight, listen to advice.”
So you ask a question on our website.

Not for the sake of a short answer, but for the sake of changing your attitude towards what happened to you, I will write with the hope of helping you return to your salvation. Without you this will not be possible. So help me.

Read the answer by clicking here

To stop this rejection and hopelessness, you need to stop looking for a return to this “miraculous” state. The status was false. That was God's permission for you. Not a visit from God, but permission.

Now the Lord, in His mercy and great long-suffering, expects you to understand the difference between grace-filled visitations and deception, so that from the very beginning of your church life the experience of discerning spirits can begin to accumulate. When clarity comes, the Lord, through renunciation of the experience that happened to you, will lead you along His paths of acquiring experience of grace, and this will be asceticism.

Two ways of working grace

There have been many cases in the history of the Church when people with a character similar to yours, persistent, taking up work with zeal, at later stages of church life were caught in deception, the fathers call it charm, and could no longer escape, they died. There were those who escaped, but then with the help of spirit-bearing elders who begged them. The cases closest to us in time are described in the book Archimandrite Cherubim « Images of modern Holy Mountain residents"(Holy Trinity Lavra of St. Sergius, 2009). The Lord saved you from future dangerous holes and potholes on the church path. But we need to carefully understand what the experience of God’s truly gracious approach to us can and should be like.

Saint Theophan the Recluse in the book " The path to salvation", summing up the ascetic experience of the holy fathers and fathers of the Church, writes about two actions of divine grace - extraordinary and ordinary or gradual. In both cases, grace directs its action to our human spirit. She awakens the spirit from sinful sleep and “draws it into the realm of Divine life.” (Reprint of the 1899 edition. The Path to Salvation, p. 89). And since our spirit is captured by three bonds of the spirit: self-indulgence, the world and the devil, then grace is “aimed at breaking these bonds of the spirit.” (Page 89). In extreme action, it immediately strikes at the very bonds and, breaking them, frees the spirit to flow there “from where it was taken - to God.” Even if she leaves a person for some time, a new state will remain with him - a certain freedom of spirit towards church life. The bonds of his spirit are broken by grace.

Is that what happened to you? No, yours is different - because - as the new state was before you visited, so it remains after it.

In the ordinary course of things, grace gradually removes many coverings of the heart, one after another, before it reaches the bonds of the spirit. Moreover, if she does the first with power and unexpectedly for the person himself, striking, destroying everything that was previously in him - his consciousness, feelings, perception of the world, she opens a new perfect life, accompanying “even a certain kind of fear” (p. 85), then in the second method of its action it conforms to a person, his jealousy, determination, readiness for work and feat.

The Apostle Paul, Mary of Egypt, the Great Martyr Barbara, the Holy Fool Andrew, Prince Jehoshaphat (Indian) and others experienced the extraordinary effect of grace. In our time, through a similar action of grace, St. Joseph the Hesychast, Hieromonk Iakim (holy Mount Athos), holy righteous John of Kronstadt.

Saint Theophan the Recluse writes that its effect affects a sinner in that he:
1) sees his sinfulness,
2) feels the danger of his position, begins to fear for himself and
3) cares about how to get rid of his misfortune and be saved.” (page 80).

The state of grace is accompanied by repentance. A repentant tone, character, state, painful sorrow towards God for oneself, sorrow for salvation - this is the surest sign of Orthodox, not even just Christian, experiences.

Third work of grace

There is a third effect of grace, when it calls a person who had not previously thought about going to church. Suddenly she awakens him from his sinful sleep, introduces him to the Church, and for two or three years gives him the experience of a living and seemingly zealous life in the Church. Then it hides in the heart, giving way to the person himself. But the man doesn’t follow her. He's not looking for her. On the one hand, he doesn’t know what to do. I am not accustomed from childhood to kindle the good in myself, to respond to the needs of loved ones, and through force, sometimes through laziness, through tightness, through I don’t want to and through fatness, I still participate with kindness and good deeds in people, peers, in my younger self.

With his moral retardation, worse than neglect, or even worse, arrogance and self-indulgent licentiousness, grace has nowhere to come in him and nothing to contribute to. A person does not do it himself good deeds, does not need the support of grace, or even simply does not want to go against himself. He is faithful to his fallen character, his habits, his worldview, he stands by his positions, views, and relationships.

Although he is a church member, by nature he has little or nothing of the Gospel in him. What is the use of praying, “reading” a lot of prayers. Such religiosity without the support of grace will not last long. At the age of 10-15, the processes of religious aging begin. Everything is going dark, there is less and less energy for prayer. Soon it may not be at all.
A person thinks that life with God means prayers and fasting, worship and sacraments. But the apostle in Romans says something different. “Christ (is) for the righteousness of everyone who believes” (Rom. 10:4).

What is righteousness? “Thou shalt love,” says Jesus, “the Lord thy God with all thy heart, and with all thy soul, and with all thy mind” (Deuteronomy 6:5). Now that we have two thousand years of experience in fulfilling this commandment given to us in the Old Testament, we know from the experience of the saints: "with all my heart"- this is when “my entire inner being is Your holy name” (from the service), or the saints say: “the sweetest name of our Lord Jesus Christ.” Not because we are so touched by the Name, but because the Name itself, pronounced in the heartfelt Jesus Prayer, being filled with grace and light, becomes sweeter. Just like honey, it is not our tenderness that makes it sweet, but it itself is filled with sweetness and the wonderful taste of wild and garden flowers.

"With all your soul"- this is “I will bless the Lord at all times,” “My soul will boast in the Lord” (Ps. 33). What is there to boast about?

The virtues of fasting, the martyrdom, the venerable and the daily virtues. Working on them “with all your soul,” “prosper righteously,” for “with these the Lord is pleased.” (Stichera on the stichera for the fourth week of Lent).

"With all Your mind"- to “understand the love of Christ that surpasses knowledge” (Eph. 3:19), “to understand the mystery which is now revealed by the Holy Spirit, so that the Gentiles also may be fellow heirs, forming one body, and partakers of the promise of God in Christ Jesus” (Eph. 3, 4-6). And the apostle says to his disciple Timothy: “May the Lord give you understanding in everything” (2 Tim. 2:7), the Lord is “He who teaches man understanding” (Ps. 93:10), when a person asks Him: “Good Teach me understanding and knowledge” (Ps. 119:66). As was the case with Daniel the prophet, to whom God gave “the understanding of every book and wisdom, and also “visions and dreams” (Dan. 1:17). “And Daniel said: With the Lord is wisdom and power, He gives wisdom to the wise and understanding to those who understand, He reveals deep and hidden things, He knows what is in the darkness, and light dwells with Him” (Dan. 2: 20-22).

If in the Old Testament times the Lord gave understanding of books and wisdom, then in the New Testament times the Holy Spirit gives understanding of the love of Christ. And for both, says the prophet Daniel, “a disposition of the heart towards understanding and humility.” (Dan. 10:12).

The lives of many saints tell us that before prayer and fasting, worship and sacraments, they had works of love, i.e. that same righteousness for the sake of which “Christ (was given to us) for the righteousness of everyone who believes” (Rom. 10:4), in order to understand and, humbly acquiring the grace of the Holy Spirit, to have in one’s soul the whole composition of virtues, and in one’s heart His Holy Name , and in His sweetest Name to love your neighbors.

Deeds of love for others

Elder Joseph of Vatopedi, a disciple of St. Joseph the Hesychast. Conversations of the elder St. about love for neighbors, as evidence of love for God. Paisius of the Svyatogorets. Filled with the highest secrets, conversations about love for people by St. Porfiria Kavsakalivita. An obvious example of ascetic love for fellow residents in the Caucasus is found in Archimandrite Vitaly. An amazing feat of love in the concentration camp of Father Arseny. St. Petersburg has marvelous gentleness and long-suffering. Abba Dorotheus. The same with St. Sergius of Radonezh to his fellow desert dwellers.

Grace accompanies each of them in acts of love. Acquired in deeds of love, deeds of righteousness - with the heart, soul and mind - grace remains with them even when they stand for prayer, perform divine services, fast, and receive the sacraments. Grace, found in acts of love, supports prayer, fasting and the sacraments. She perfects them and is herself multiplied by them. Thus righteousness is elevated to holiness.

And on the contrary, there are many examples when prayer, fasting, divine services and sacraments prescribed according to the rules, especially in monasteries, and in the world by many, are regularly performed, but at the same time the monks or laity have a difficult and difficult disposition. They try to establish discipline and rules, but at the same time they do not tolerate the meek next to them, they envy the humble, they swear and plot against the obedient. Consider the evil deeds of the brethren against Abba Dorotheus, when one of them in the morning released his liquid directly into the face of the sleeping Dorotheus, and several others from time to time shook out their bedding with bedbugs and fleas at the door of his cell. Or the older brother of St. Sergius of Radonezh, Stefan organized a whole conspiracy against him in the monastery. And in the world, such external church life established anger, betrayal and slander, which began to foam in abundance in the immediate circle of Tsar Nicholas II and Tsarina Alexandra. But many of them had a very visible Orthodox way of life.

Haven't they read the Gospel? Can't be. Read it. Maybe they didn't understand him? How can one not understand when on every page there are words about love, or deeds of love, or many people who need love and receive it. No, it’s not a matter of reading or understanding. There is something different in people when they don’t want to love. What about the Lord? For some reason, with unstoppable hope, he continues to say: “This is My commandment, that you love one another, as I have loved you. Greater love has no one than this, that someone lay down his life for his friends” (John 15:12-13). You cannot do it on your own, but “the Comforter, the Holy Spirit, will come and teach you all things and remind you of everything that I have said to you” (John 14:26). And “by this everyone will know that you are My disciples, if you have love for one another” (John 13:35). “If you know these things, blessed are you when you do them” (John 13:17).

Thus, having spoken about love for each other as the primary works of faith, which are primarily supported by the grace of the Holy Spirit, the Lord repeatedly and with the most different turns of speech says and says almost the same thing: “If you love Me, keep My commandments” (John. 14,15). “Whoever has My commandments and keeps them, he loves Me, and whoever loves Me will be loved by My Father,” “He who does not love Me does not keep My words” (John 14:21,24). And these words are not about prayer and fasting, not about worship and the sacrament, but about love for each other. And after the words about love for each other, in other places, not the most central ones, there are words about means - about prayer and fasting, about worship. And only the words about the sacrament of communion are especially worthwhile. “He who eats Me will live by Me” (John 6:57).

Such a one “abides in Me, and I in him.” “Whoever eats (Me) will not die”, but will “have eternal life” (John 6:50,54), and such one “bears much fruit”, “and you will be My disciples” - “love one another” (John. 15,5,8,17). “Your fruit is holiness, but the end is eternal life” (Rom. 6:23).

What is He talking about when He says, “Bears much fruit”? This speaks of the fruits of righteousness. They are to love with all my heart"His holy name" to with all my soul, that is, to love our neighbors with many different virtues, and to with all my mind“to understand the love of Christ,” which is love for people.

Bug that has spread

That's what error Many people in the Church today say that they have put the works of prayer, fasting and worship in first place, and some in the only place. They devoted all their energy to them, giving them all their religious time. And they do not suspect that the religious life commanded by the Lord in the Gospel is love for neighbors, that is, love for those whom the Lord has chosen and loves, and for the sake of this His love of God sends the Holy Spirit to us.

And the Spirit, cleansing our fallen love from sin, makes it righteous and then, sanctifying it, elevates it to holiness. And prayer, fasting, vigil and many ascetic deeds serve as a means of acquiring grace, so that through it one can ultimately ascend into communion with God.

In that communion with God, the beginning of which is love for one’s neighbors, the middle of which is the practice of prayer, and the culmination of which is the appearance of Christ in His Name, in heartfelt prayer.

In those cases when a person in life, in behavior, in actions, ignoring the Gospel (maybe reading it every day as a rule), devotes himself entirely to prayer, fasting and worship, does he understand what he is doing, does he understand, Why is he doing this? Experience shows that with this nature of religious life, over the years the reserve of religious forces for these actions is lost and a person becomes impoverished in them.

It is not enough that by doing according to the commandments of love for others, a person refuses helping grace. And at the same time, without realizing it, he is looking for it where it is not, and is becoming more and more convinced that while searching and working, he does not find it.

The grace hidden in his heart freezes as if unclaimed, and after two or three decades of church life (visible and external) has passed, it begins to move away from the person. The result is that before us is a man who seems to be a believer and religious, but with a character ineradicably devoted to everything that has fallen in himself, and over the years, more and more difficult and even unbearable for those around him. This is what Elder Kirill (Pavlov) was talking about when answering the question: “Will Russia be reborn?” He said after a pause: “We need to revive morality.”

When in our time we often and everywhere talk about rude, intolerant, money-grubbing or money-loving ministers of churches, when families, while remaining church members, find it increasingly difficult to live with each other, or married couples get divorced, when children under 12 years of age actively attended Sunday schools and worship services, and when they came in adolescence and youth, disappear from churches and, with increased energy, devote themselves to the affairs of the world, when adults experience an impoverishment of faith or a burnout of ministerial zeal, then we have the result of a mistaken passion for religious actions, religious rational, and essentially self-loving education in various church and spiritual schools and abundant religious reading while simultaneously ignoring the religious life commanded to us in acts of love with our neighbors.

Apparently, Gregory, you also made this mistake. Now we need to fix it.

Post-mortem revelations

In the meantime, let's continue testing what happened to you.

The experience you have had is closer to what we have today. different types experienced by a number of people. What you experienced was not what you had. But we experienced it just as much as you. These are Alexander, Elena, Andrey, who made a splash with their stories. They had a posthumous experience, after which they returned with a mission to tell not only about what they saw and heard beyond the grave, but also about earthly events that are happening and will happen. Their states and experiences are close to yours.

Is this experience from God?

If something comes to us from the other world with the blessing of God, it comes for imitation by those about whom we are talking, or for those remaining on earth to increase the fear of God in us. These are the stories about the ordeal of Blessed Theodora. Other things are given to us to strengthen in us the feeling of God’s infinite mercy and love for us. These are the revelations about the heavenly abodes and walks through them.

In the revelations of Alexander, Elena, Andrey there is a lot of information of a seemingly very serious nature. Similar news on TV - about upcoming changes, for example, in the ruble exchange rate - are very, more than serious and also give rise to a lot of anxiety. Similar ones. But when we talk about spiritual health, then it is not the information that is important, but the effect it has on a person. Nowadays, so much information bombards us that we need to be able to shake ourselves off from some if we have allowed ourselves too much exposure, and from others, recognizing them, learn to distance ourselves.

There is much in the above revelations that removes those who listen to them from true spiritual experiences. These revelations rock people's consciousness, awakening and nourishing something alive in them. But this living thing turns out to be animal fear, mixed with religious feeling, fear for one’s fate, for the fate of one’s loved ones.

On the other hand, the content of the revelations given as an example, telling about events in modern Church, present and future, reveals much that is recognizable in what is and is anticipated as a probable course of development of future events.

But there is characteristic feature- these revelations stir up in a person the desire to evaluate everything that is reported, and with them a voluntary or involuntary reproach of what they reproach is generated. It is very difficult for a person who is not seriously strengthened in self-reproach not to become infected with strong embarrassment and excitement at what seems to be happening in our Church now.

It then takes a lot of time to calm down, even more to shake off the seized contents, and not everyone will come to their senses, that is, to what the saints teach about - the fear of God and self-reproach.

And only when a person comes to the fear of God, then will he feel that he has entered a safe island and returned in his worldview to the bosom of Orthodoxy.

Unfortunately, a lot of people don’t come to this. Look, people bring amazing news from the other world, as if for the benefit of those living on earth. At the same time, they themselves experience a clear awakening to church life, despite the fact that they had almost no life before. True, awakening to external life. In order to now move from external life to internal life, it will be necessary to follow the Gospel in the sacraments of the Church. It will be necessary to encounter warnings about such experiences in the Gospel in order to distance oneself from them.

And we will have to stumble upon ourselves, when for them, having experienced the post-mortem experience, and for their listeners, The Lord's gospel warning has already will not be valid.

Then, to be heard Gospel, it will be necessary take the path of acquiring grace. And this will be the ordinary, as St. Theophan the Recluse calls it, method of acquisition.

Many people today went on pilgrimage trips to holy places. Some have been to the Holy Land, and some to Athos. Almost everyone, upon returning, tried to retain their impressions and preserve the new knowledge they had experienced. But time inexorably ate everything up. And impressions, and knowledge, and novelty gradually disappeared. But right after the trip they thought that they could live on this forever.

The same thing happens to those who have had post-mortem experiences. As you move away from it, it is erased.

Therefore, both in an awakened, but external religious life, and in the remnants of impressions that return with admiration to what has been experienced, it is easy for a person to become susceptible to various temptations.
Therefore, you need to hear at least one thing - to think that you can live endlessly with the impressions you receive was a mistake.

Live long, i.e. you can only go on the path.

Three ways

True, many people tend to go to the sidelines. They don't live on the sidelines. They wait, rest, squander their inheritance or their earnings, move from one thing to another without moving anywhere, celebrate, exist, vegetate, and so on. We're not talking about the side of the road. We're talking about paths. If we talk about paths, there are apparently three of them. Life path earthly, the path of the Lord to heaven and for the sake of heaven, and the path to nowhere.

Life path on earth - this is the discovery of moral values ​​in oneself and development in them. What are moral assets? These are conscience, goodness, life callings, religiosity and labor force. Five. What are life callings? There are also five of them - filial, matrimonial, parental, ancestral and domestic. These are callings of love. The first three - marital, parental and filial - form a family. The ancestral vocation of love forms the clan and family relationships. The Fatherland is formed by the paternal calling of love for the Motherland, compatriots, and country. Labor power ensures the earthly living conditions of the family, clan, and Fatherland.

I am writing about this as it would seem about truisms, but ones that are disappearing before our eyes from the sight of modern people. Everything named for modern people begins to be boring, old, that is, not modern, and besides, also annoying. But it is precisely in the implementation of what is written here that man’s earthly path lies. That is, in the implementation of a good and holy family, a morally strong family over generations and a God-blessed Fatherland.

The Way of the Lord - this is the path of asceticism, moral and spiritual. Fight your passions as the parents of sin. For this, people run away from the objects of passion from the world into monasteries and behind their fence they work on obedience to God, that is, on fulfilling the commandments of the Gospel with the participation of divine grace from Him. The zealous ones move on. They embark on the path of battle with fallen nature. To do this, they choose such living conditions in which fallen nature has nothing to console itself with. This is life in the mountains, forests, deserts, where there is nowhere to lay your head, life alone or in two or three, with the banishment of any everyday comforts. Under these conditions, fallen nature first rages, defending itself and undermining the ascetic to escape from the desert, at least to a monastery, or even to the world. When this fails, then he attracts demonic forces to help, in order to drive him out of the desert with insurance and seduction. And if nothing helps, then it itself begins to languish and fade away, to fall and give way to grace, prayer, love for God in prayer and in the fulfillment of gospel love for all people.

Path to nowhere
Far from these two paths - life's and the Lord's - the third path - to nowhere - is categorically different. In the history of mankind, it is carried out in two forms - eastern and western. Without any concealment, it is presented as a frank mystical path into nothingness in Eastern religions, among Eastern peoples. In Taoism (Tao Te Ching) it is called the “Canon of the Path and Perfection.” This is a small book written by the ancient Chinese sage Lao Tzu in the 5th-4th centuries BC (BC). Lao Tzu was apparently a contemporary of Confucius. There is a legend about their meetings. Already by the 3rd-2nd centuries, the book begins to acquire interpretations and gradually becomes an extensive teaching on how to live.

The first part of the book “Tao” is devoted to the path, the second – to perfection. The path is ultimately called heavenly, has a name Great Path. Revealed in the following words. The subtlest secret, a subtle-elusive essence, movement in refinement: “in concealment there is still concealment: that is where refinement comes from.” As a result, “the path is an emptiness that contains everything.

Elusive! It precedes the Supreme Lord! Like the Great Absence." Great Peace. The Supreme Overlord is a (Supreme Deity dating back to the Shang era). Which precedes the Path.

This Supreme Deity reveals himself as dragon.

Interpreter Jiang-sheng draws attention to the words used by Lao Tzu, the author of the Tao. These words are “as if”, “seemingly”, “seemingly”. In them, the “elusive Divinity,” writes Jiang-sheng, either reveals itself or disappears: “the dragon will appear and disappear, at different times it will show its horns and its claws, making it clear that it is immeasurable.” This is the same dragon to which so many holidays in China and Japan are dedicated.

Let me note by the way how in our time the three words “as if”, “seemingly”, “seems” are generously sprinkled throughout the speech of most, if not all, people indiscriminately - believers, non-believers, church people, non-church people. There is one more word that almost everyone prefaces their response to something said. When a person answers, he first says “no and”, and then says what he wants to say. I usually respond to this by remarking to the person with the phrase: “there is no grace for “no.” The word “as if” in our speech is pronounced abbreviated: “as if.”

And who doesn’t like to put this word in front of those words in their speech that have good or divine content. “I seemed to wish him well,” “he seemed to help everyone,” “everyone, imagine how much they loved each other.” I noticed that people don’t say “as if” before swear words. They immediately say: “he is harmful and evil.” There would be no way to say: “he’s kind of harmful and kind of evil.” No, they don't say that. Evil and bad things are pronounced affirmatively, without any “as if.”

The essence of the “Tao” was taught to the masses of the people for one purpose - so that the people could revolve in a religious space in which there is no God.

For followers of another teaching - Buddhism, God is so distant that those without mystical talents do not even need to think about Him. It is enough to know the teachings about karma, about the cycle of births of samsara, about the world of suffering, about the pre-existence of souls, about deities that protect from misfortunes and deities that help in life, and to participate in simple religious practices of worshiping them.

As a result, all of Tibet and India, where Buddhism was born, are filled with statues of monsters - demonic entities with bared mouths, claws, fangs. They are worshiped. Alas, not only in India and Tibet. Here in Russia, many people became acquainted with Hinduism in its various branches (Bhagavad Gita, Vivekananda), and with Buddhism in its various interpretations. They believed in the teachings of the East mentioned above - about the pre-existence of souls, about karma, about the cycle of samsara, about horoscopes.

What did this lead to? To an obvious change in consciousness. The thought, consciousness and imagination of people began to revolve and live in the near-earth invisible air space, in the heavens. Without needing Heaven. Alone of these, the content of the teachings and the “heavenly” consciousness began to explain personal earthly events and what is happening in the lives of people’s closest circle. Fill your life with superstitions, predictions, cause-and-effect relationships of karma, samsara, and the movement of souls.

Other began to master the practices that accompany these teachings - meditations, rituals, services, exercises. For the first and second, “heavenly” knowledge is drawn into earthly life and fills it with its content, and for those engaged in practice, the latter is filled with the energies of this knowledge.

The third and fourth, through acquaintance with the teachings and the special structure of their religious and mystical feelings, experience revelations from “under heaven”. So do third- this is the experience of communicating with mystical entities, explicit or in sensations.

U fourth– experience of contact with various mystical energies. One of the results of such revelations is healing, either guided and performed by the participation of demonic forces, or performed “by sensation.” The same mystical practice includes the recently introduced “weaving” or “weaving” of mothers after childbirth.

In the east in their religious tradition Hinduism and Buddhism, those who have great claims to religious life, mystical practice guides further, through contemplation - samadhi - directly leads to demonization, or Enlightenment, in which there is a renunciation of one’s own personality and dissolution in nirvana, leads to “nothing”, or “such a complete disappearance after which nothing remains” (Mahaparinibbana Sutta).

Western route to nowhere
In the rest of the Western world, the same path “to nowhere”, but not mystical, but earthly is presented as permanent shift civilizations. When one earthly civilization, having reached some of its limits for mysterious reasons, suddenly goes out, disappears, leaving behind ruins for archaeologists and historians, or a certain number of preserved cultural monuments - material, written, or ethnic traditions passed on and slowly fading over centuries. Time passes and only historians and people interested in history, tourists, and museum visitors know about the recently triumphant civilization.

From this position, any earthly civilization and activity in it or for its sake is a path to nowhere. Whatever the scale of this activity.

In the Gospel, this space of life, where people live in nowhere, is called the kingdom of the prince of this world. Or the kingdom of darkness. What moves people in this space of life is their own active force. It must be distinguished from labor force.

Nowadays the entire modern world lives by active force. It is associated with the talents, creative abilities and spiritual gifts of people. All matters of science, culture and education are done by her. It is by this that all political, economic and social life. If labor force is rooted in moral forces and assets, then active force is directly based on the bonds of the spirit in man.

But let's return to the Tao. Interpreter Cao Xinyi, guiding to the practical implementation of the “Tao,” writes: “Keep the pre-heaven energy intact, remove obstacles to the innermost vision, the heavenly gate is the heart itself.” After this, the “Tao” itself says the following about the state of the heart: “Mercy is a disgrace: beware of it. What does it mean? Mercy for us is humiliation. Be afraid when you get it, be afraid when you lose it. Truly, “the one who values ​​himself more than the world can be entrusted with the world” (“Tao”, chapter 13). Compare with this the words of Holy Scripture: “All the ways of the Lord are mercy and truth” (Ps. 24:10). “The Lord is good, His mercy endures forever” (Ps. 99:5). “I am the Lord who shows kindness” (Jer. 9:24). “Woe to you, scribes and Pharisees, for you have abandoned the most important things in the law: judgment, mercy and faith” (Matthew 23:23). But let us “come boldly to the throne, that we may receive mercy and find grace” (Heb. 4:16).

Now read how Western translators translate the words of “Tao” even more frankly: “Mercy and shame are equally fearful.” Another translation: “Mercy dishonors: it is like fetters.” (R. Henrichs). Finally, the interpretive creativity of Western translators reaches such a revolution in meaning that it begins to contradict even the “Tao” itself: “He who values ​​the Celestial Empire more than himself can be entrusted with the Celestial Empire” (A. A. Maslov). But the following words of “Tao” almost justify Maslov’s translation: “To adhere to the Path of the ancients in order to command those now existing, and to know the Primordial Beginning - this is the basis and thread of the Path.” (Tao, chapter 14). “That is why a wise man, controlling people, empties their heads and fills their bellies” (Tao, chapter 3). How can one not remember “The Protocols of the Elders of Zion” now?

There is one more observation that is striking in its frankness. This is how the European consciousness, brought up on philosophical treatises, enthusiastically accepts the “Tao” and, almost reveling in it, recognizes something of its own in it, finds food, confirmation, and justification for itself. Listen to how Europe explains, interprets and continues the Tao.

“The path is a refined space of perfect communication.” “The path of all paths, one Great Transformation, the absolute Event as the co-existence of all things. He is nothing other than boundless ultimacy, an inexhaustible wealth of diversity without idea or principle, without form or substance. It exists, but has no essence. He has an absent, symbolic depth. Representing an eternal cycle from oneself to oneself (devoid of reality and extension), such a Beginning has internal completeness.” (M. 2003, pp. 45-46).

This is one of the interpretations, explanations of the “Tao”, made with a European claim to depth, with that subtle pride in symbolism and abstraction, in which there is nothing to rely on, there is not a single tangible object. “The reality of the self-absence of beings, in the act of dispersion, in the infinite wealth of diversity.” And there are not two pages of such text, but 87! And these texts are apparently intended for people with a new, modern education. Those. for people with European consciousness.

The Tao itself adds to this. “Higher people, having learned about the Path, show zeal and implement it. Ordinary people, having learned about the Path, partly follow it, partly do not. Low people, having learned about the Path, laugh loudly at it. If they didn’t laugh, it wouldn’t be the Way” (Tao, ch. 41). The language of “Tao” is a language comprehended, according to H. G. Gadamer, as “the all-encompassing pre-interpretation of the world” or “the all-encompassing openness of being.” It is a language that returns to pure communication; existence gapes in it. The meeting of the openness of the heart with the unconditional openness of existence. The central concept of Tao is the concept of “all-encompassing emptiness.” (page 23). The question involuntarily arises: what is the European language? Gaping of what? And what kind of existence does openness give? And is there anything to exist in this language?

Spirit Bonds

But let us now return to Saint Theophan the Recluse. How he describes the bonds of the spirit.

The bonds of the spirit are peace, self-indulgence and the devil, respectively, the bonds from here take their name: the bonds of peace, self-indulgence and the bonds of the devil. The latter is tangible to a person and is more recognizable to us as pride and pride. However, behind this, according to St. Theophan the Recluse, lies the following: “The third bonds of the spirit come from Satan and his spirits. They are invisible and for the most part coincide with the bonds of self-indulgence and peace. But there is something that comes directly from Satan.

From him there is some vague timidity and fear when he (a person) thinks about good. From him various spiritual flatteries: alone excessive, without true foundations, hope in God’s mercy, not sobering, but increasingly deepening into love of sin (indulging); at others– despair; at this– doubt and unbelief; at Togo- self-confidence and self-justification, drowning out any feeling of remorse.

One of his cunning tricks is to hide himself, that is, to make the sinner believe that he does not exist, (as a result) he acts without permission with ferocity in the sinful soul (those vices that are characteristic of every individual person).

In the days of the Lord on earth, demons, the source of unbelief and doubt, became preachers of the faith, (forced by the saints) to speak the truth (about themselves, who they are) through idols and idols in the temples.

Such a revelation of the machinations of the evil one leads the sinner (who believed them) to the discovery that he is in evil and enemy hands, that he is being fooled to his own detriment, that he is being deceptively led along some dark path to destruction and wants to rejoice in it.

(In a prudent sinner) this inevitably gives rise to a feeling of fear for his own good, caution, disgust for the cunning man and his inventions - seductions, vices and passions, and for his entire previous life according to his teachings. (The Path to Salvation. Reprint from the 1899 edition, pp. 95-96).

From this aversion from the demonic world begins the path to overcoming one’s own spiritual bonds, to which a person spontaneously finds himself betrayed. Then a person begins to really live, having in his life the gracious participation of the Holy Spirit in his moral movements. With this grace-filled participation, everything inside him begins to be released in that moral primordial purity in which God once created Adam. For this reason, work on acquiring grace, acquiring the Holy Spirit becomes a person’s life. He is no longer on the sidelines, he is on the path. And here you have to go until you arrive.

To death, and after it - to resurrection and eternal life.
This is why you need to acquire grace along the way, otherwise there will be nothing to go on.
To acquire, you need ways, means and conditions.
And to them shocks. Without them, grace cannot be acquired.
It is necessary to shake off the bonds of the spirit, and to do this, shake off the causative agents of sin, which St. speaks of. Theophan, and from sinful character strengtheners.
And about the external, the Lord already says: “ beware lest anyone deceive you"(Matthew 24:4).
And he also says: “ Woe to the world from temptations: for temptations must come"(Matthew 18:7).
And further: But you “ watch yourself"(Luke 17:3).
The Lord speaks so persistently about this because He foresees that by our time His warnings will not have any force for many, and various revelations, of which there will be many in recent times, will forcefully cause a lot of unrest.
Again, so are we. What are we talking about and why are we talking about all this? About that, Gregory, and in order to say that not every supernatural experience is an experience from God. Even in world religions. And perhaps even more so in them.
But if it is allowed to someone in Russia, it is always for the sake of shock. Both from self-delusion and from its cause. So it is for the experience of distinguishing spiritual states.

Supernatural false revelations

Let us now touch on another experience. It is closer to you, but also not entirely yours; the experience is vivid and fascinating. So, for example, having experienced a powerful revelation, as if from above, a man born without arms, without legs, jumping with joy, now preaches Christ throughout Europe and lifts up and glorifies the name “Jesus” in front of thousands of audiences. Protestants take this experience very close to their hearts, Catholics look and hear about it with a sense of surprise, and Orthodox Christians look at it as if it were an overseas curiosity. Why is it a curiosity?

Because, having the spirit of Christ, and it lives in a person in the fear of God, involuntarily, and perhaps not entirely clearly at first, but over time more and more clearly, you will distance yourself from this Western experience. In this seemingly Christian joy and similar to your “love and compassion without selectiveness for everyone and everything,” in a strong and convincing sermon to love life and love to live, the inner feeling of a Christian seeks and does not find those dear to the heart repentant feelings, intimate touches meekness Christ and His humility. Doesn't find the one quietness heart, in which the soul lives, capable of receiving blessing Christlike, accept world Christ, which sounds and is given from above at every liturgy in the commandments beatitudes.

Or, similar in source, where it comes from, i.e. not at all from Christ, but completely opposite in appearance - “Confessions of a Satanist.” (The film is posted on the Internet). A Satanist, raised from childhood in the family of a sorcerer and a witch, who has reached the highest rank among all the sorcerers of the world, the closest collaborator of the devil, who has brewed many people in America into a mystical, sinful mess, suddenly stumbles upon the sign of Christ - the cross, and goes through a series of devastating events for him. pride, embarrassment, and eventually becomes an evangelical Christian, renounces the devil and now reveals to the whole world the most hidden secrets of Satanism.

It’s amazing and scary to listen to how the devil works with people today, how people, by their own irresistible attraction, plunge themselves in thousands into small and large and large-scale tricks of the devil, are caught spontaneously and freely either through their own superstitious or mystical fears, or through everyday multi-various self-interest to have more , or through claims to become big and great in the world, they are caught by giving themselves up with all of themselves and plunging all of themselves into the satanic trends in the world, into the actions of the spirit of the time and into the civilizational prospects of a contented earthly life.

But this is not the essence of the revelations of the former Satanist. “Many will come in My name, and will deceive many. Do not be dismayed, says the Lord, for all these things must come to pass.” (Matt. 24:5-6). The essence of the revelations of the former Satanist is to lead many people to His name, Christ, with these revelations.

It would seem to Christ? No. IN Christianity. Into a Christianity in which in the minds of people sin will be divorced from the fallen nature of man. Then Christians will try to do something about sin, without touching the fallen nature in yourself. This is how it will be by nature all world Christianity.

False Christs and False Prophets

The hidden, invisible work of the enemy of the human race is accomplished in brewing sin in many people. If you stir flour in water, over time it will settle into sediment and the water will become light. But if the mess is boiled, boiled, the resulting flour paste cannot be returned to its original state. Therefore, the enemy wants not only to plunge a person into sin, but to brew sin in a person, irreparably spoiling his nature. To brew and multiply is what the devil wants and is looking for.

Then, with the corruption of nature and the cooling of love, a person easily enters or gives himself over to the kingdom of lawlessness. The words of the Lord given here are difficult and sorrowful, that many will be deceived by the name of the Lord. Without distinguishing between spirits, people will enter the same kingdom of lawlessness, confessing themselves under that “My name” under which the deceivers will come. They will call themselves Christians, counting themselves among world Christianity.

The work of the spirits of flattery has begun on this in our days. The idea of ​​universal, universal Christianity - it will be that final temptation and those networks of deception with which the enemy of the human race will triumphantly collect his bountiful catch. “False Christs and false prophets will arise and show great signs and wonders to deceive, if possible, even the elect,” “and many false prophets will arise and deceive many.” (Matt. 24, 24, 11). “False Christs” are those “under my name.” All mostly from simple people.

“False prophets” are those who will be in power. And it is said: “They will deceive many,” because they will be in power. And “many” are people who have no other support in church life other than “power.” They go through life with her blessing and rely on her. Not so much on the holy fathers, although they may be well-read in them, and not on the experience of grace, although somewhere and somehow they experienced it, and not on the tradition of the Church, in which more often and more they will adhere not to the tradition itself, but to that , which is convenient.

For example, reduced services, a charter changed in the Western style. They will not realize that by such manipulations with Tradition they lose spiritual life and are absorbed into religious-spiritual life. This is absorption into religious-spiritual life, the peak of which, i.e. performance skills are increasingly determined by human talents and professionalism, and there is a great sorrow of our time.

Soulful Christians are characterized by two types of behavior, like two branches coming from one root. One is when they calmly treat any changes in church life, and do not attach any importance to the content of these changes. Another type of behavior, when a person reacts sharply to changes in church life, gives them such serious significance, as if the very foundations of life were being broken. The first behave so carelessly because they rely on the authority or power of priests and bishops. The latter behave this way because they rely on own opinion, have their own position.

Hence, it is easy for them, the latter, to come into conflict with church authorities. They may even believe that by conflicting with church authorities, they are thereby protecting and defending Orthodoxy. Why do these two types of behavior arise from the same dispensation? Because they are generated by a soulful person. He lives by himself, his human nature. Therefore, depending on his inherent character and the supports that make up his life, he behaves according to the first type of behavior, or according to the second, or fluctuates in the middle between the first and second.

Speaking about false prophets, let us add to what has been said - false prophets, as people of a spiritual nature, do not need supernatural experience. By their natural and sometimes outstanding talents or by their official position of power, and ultimately by conceit and self-confidence, they will feel and place themselves as if much higher than everything supernatural.

Not only false, but also real, valid. Moreover, having an official spiritual education, as a tool from which they will have a pre-compiled answer to everything and about everything, they will treat with arrogance and disgust not only the deceived, i.e. lost in magic, but also to those who are led by real grace.

They will not distinguish between one and the other, treating everything with equal hatred based on only one criterion - this is supernatural. They are drawn to the words of the Lord, and when reading them, they do not recognize themselves in them, or, if they recognize it, it is not to understanding, but to annoyance and irritation. Because they will value only the knowledge acquired in educational structures, and those natural human talents that they will cherish and develop in themselves. At the same time, for the sake of the stability of earthly life, including religious life, they will, with inspiration and determination, create new types of earthly organizations and superstructures above them that are completely natural from a spiritual point of view.

These organizations and superstructures will take on an increasingly powerful and global character. And people will trust them and the newly emerging forms of its organization more than the tradition of the Church. They will know the tradition of the Church in a school, book way, but in life they will not know and recognize it either. There is nothing, because there is no morality.

Thus, through a seemingly natural arrangement and initiative improvement of church life and the seemingly natural course of historical events, unfolding on the basis of agreement in some cases and power in others, the devil will, and already is, build his kingdom on earth. For this, he and for such people in our time do not need supernatural signs. They will be needed only at the last stage, when the Antichrist will have to reveal himself as God. This is how things stand with spiritual people who have no taste for the beatitudes and who have somehow lost repentance.

And in relation to, albeit towards a smaller number of people (true, there are millions of them) who have an inclination towards the supernatural, but also spiritual people, the devil will seek “to deceive them with signs and wonders” (Matthew 24:24). That is, to gather them into the same single kingdom on earth. Therefore, today, at one pole, a joyful Protestant, born without arms, without legs, at the other, a former Satanist who became an evangelist, they will be talking about the same thing - about Christ. They will gather around themselves those who, by their nature, want to be deceived.

"By its nature", i.e. he is looking for peace, comfort in earthly life and security, so that nothing threatens him from anywhere. This is all he will be given. Moreover, from the source that is the source of seduction for both of them is the same - the mystical world of demons and demons.

And the reason is sincere character their religious life, which is based on the desired conditions of earthly existence - peace and security. The people I cited as an example, who experienced a supernatural experience, did not themselves come to Orthodoxy, and those who believe them also usually do not begin to seek Orthodoxy, or even if the Orthodox listen to these revelations, they do not turn to the ascetic life, as to the actual Orthodoxy.

It turns out that for them the shock they experienced from what they heard is enough, and for the first it is enough to know that there is Christ and to believe in Him, but they go no further. Neither internal nor external - nothing tells them that finding Christ is a spiritual and moral work, the work of acquiring grace.

Moreover, the acquisition of grace in the ordinary way that is described by St. Theophan the Recluse in his book “The Path to Salvation”, i.e. – ascetic life in the Orthodox Church. Not so much by church services, they are also needed, but above all by ascetic life. But for those seeking peace and security in religious and in earthly life in general, this ordinary method of acquiring grace is not needed. It is enough for them to simply be religious and, as it were, Orthodox people. There are those among us who say: “I am Orthodox, I am baptized, and God is inside me, in my heart. Why else would I go to church?” Or: “I go to church, pray, fast, take communion. What else do you need? And they are happy with it.

Three unclean spirits

“And I saw,” says the seer of the Apocalypse, “coming out of the mouth of the dragon and the mouth of the beast, and from the mouth of the false prophet, three unclean spirits like frogs. These are demonic spirits performing signs; they go out to the kings of the earth of the whole world to gather them for battle... Blessed is he who watches and keeps his clothes, lest he walk naked and lest they see his shame.” (Rev. 16:13-15).

This is what Archpriest Gennady Fast writes about these “unclean spirits” in the book “Interpretation of the Apocalypse” (M. Nikea, 2009) - “we see in the dragon, the beast and the false prophet the satanic “trinity.” The Trinity is not essentially, but imitative and false. Satan personally comes into action and attracts his most powerful servants: the Antichrist and the false prophet (the civilization of recent and our times - A.G.). From the mouths of Satan, the Antichrist, and the false prophet come three unclean spirits. “These are demonic spirits doing signs” (Rev. 16:14). Their goal is to captivate and seduce people. “Blessed is he who is awake,” who did not bow down to the Antichrist, but waited for Christ, and “kept his garment” received in baptism and always clothed his soul with good deeds, “so that he would not walk naked” from good deeds, and “so that they would not see his shame.” , that is, the fallen sinful nature” (pp. 265-267).

To these words, Rev. Gennady Fast we will add a question:

Why do we see civilization in the false prophet? Because, pay attention, it is precisely the prophetic mechanism that actively supports its development. It always calls for another idea of ​​the future, which masses of people who are far from spiritual life believe in as another prophecy about a new life.

They not only believe, but in millions and organized ranks they enthusiastically pick up the next idea-prophecy and devote themselves to it with all their passionate strength. Just look at the parades and demonstrations of the Soviet anti-God period, the orderly ranks of fascist troops with their arms raised in a single “Heil”, at the huge masses of people at Catholic masses in Vatican Square. That is why the apostle’s warning sounds so timely and modern: “Let us therefore not sleep, like others, but let us watch and be sober” (1 Thess. 5:6).

Deification, atheization, demonization

But let’s return, Gregory, to you. Your case is not quite the same as those who have had a post-mortem experience and then carry this news to many. It does not quite coincide with those who, unexpectedly for themselves, having experienced a certain visitation, became bright preachers of Christ. You haven't started doing either of these.

In the history of mankind there have been many mystics who experienced something supernatural, grabbed hold of it and began to develop the practice of holding this visitation. At the same time, through communication with certain demonic entities, we received many revelations from them. People began to flock to them, follow them, learn from them. This is how great religions arose with their content, cult and mystical practices. So from these religions arose the sects that followed them: the Hare Krishnas, the sects of Vivekananda, Muna and many others like them. This multiplication and multiplication of branches always occurs where the Holy Spirit is not present.

None of these religions and the branches that have separated from them lead to Christ. The mystical practices of these religions, especially the Eastern ones, lead to the demonization of man. Note that, in contrast to them, the Orthodox mystical practice of asceticism at high levels of prayer practice leads to deification.

Catholic Christians and Protestants do not have the mystical practice of asceticism.

In 1054, having broken off their relationship with Orthodoxy, they actually lost the participation of the Holy Spirit in them, and from that time on they began to lose the feeling of the Holy Spirit, the feeling of grace. More and more, it began to be replaced and replaced by a feeling of self-realization in mental and carnal initiative. As a result, instead of Orthodox asceticism, they were left with only content and cult. And many socially significant movements and ministries, until the energy and convictions accumulate for some next pandemic for the whole world. True, Catholics have monasteries and monastic life. But they do not actually have a mystical life of repentance and grace.

Because their religious practice comes from a fallen nature and does not go beyond the boundaries of an overheated fallen one. And the further Catholicism moves in historical time, the more it surrenders to the influence of fallen spirits.

True, the same thing is happening today in Orthodoxy, in that Orthodoxy that lives from fallen nature. In this Orthodoxy, over the past two centuries, there has been a loss of morality, caused by a crushing change in the way of life.

That way of life in which the active principles are harmony, the sacrament of the Church and the aspiration of eternal life. That way of life in which the chastity of the family, the chastity of the clan, the people lives, and from these three the chastity of an individual is formed - a child, a teenager, a youth, an adult, an old one. This is exactly the case if we are talking about the people as a whole - from the general to the specific, and not vice versa. And if private, i.e. an individual who comes from such a people will personally take the path of increasing chastity, then “thousands will be saved around him.” Of the order in which the fallen is overcome by holy morality, chastity is based on “veneration of holiness,” and in the image and structure of the order lies the prototype of the Kingdom of Heaven in the sacraments of the Church, primarily in the sacrament of the Eucharist and in its continuation “in liturgy after liturgy” ( Patriarch Alexy II).

This way of life was the main target on which all the global mechanisms of modern civilization of the 19th and 20th centuries fell. The way of life was destroyed everywhere and at all levels, giving the field of life of the family, clan, people and Church to a triumph of fallen nature unprecedented in previous history.

Fallen nature or this world in these historical events Recently, the way of life has been redrawn many times to its own discord. It, fallen nature, became the basis of the life of everyone and everything - society, country, Church.

And even in advanced church meetings it began to occupy a leading place. The holy ascetics prophesied about this when they said that the world, and this is fallen nature, would enter monasteries in recent times.

Life from a fallen nature, with all its seemingly Orthodox religiosity, which has an external character, led Russia to the revolution of the 17th year. A person who lives fallen in himself is an individual, not a person. With the Fall, personality was lost in Paradise. The development of the individual began on earth.

What is he like? He continues to be characterized by religiosity. He's soulful. He has many talents and is active. Such a person cannot return to himself - personality. He doesn't know her. Only God, as the creator of personality, knows it. He can also revive it in a person.

Restoration of personality occurs through asceticism as deification occurs, and this is given by the Holy Spirit. The Holy Spirit, by His grace, awakens a person to Christ. This begins in the sacrament of baptism - in the sacrament of spiritual birth. Moreover, we must understand that there is a blood birth, and there is a spiritual birth. Consanguineous birth occurs from mothers and from women.

But fathers already give birth spiritually. God gives them His blessing to build a family, they are given God’s power from above to raise children together with their mothers as children of God, as the people of God. It is not for nothing that in the Gospel the genealogy of Christ goes through the fathers. “Abraham begat Isaac; Isaac gave birth to Jacob..." And at the end the Mother of God, "from whom Jesus was born" (Matthew 1, 2, 16). Born not from human seed, but from above from the Holy Spirit, i.e. spiritual birth, the birth of divine blessing, descending from Heaven, like the fathers. Thus, God lays the foundation in the born Christ “to resurrect the fallen image.”

But such a course of historical development and life is opposed by the fallen individual. Through the dignity of his humanity, he rises into pride, and in pride - to the extreme - into atheism. The twentieth century is a time of the atheization of man. The emergence of millions of people who do not believe in either God or the devil, who believe only in themselves, in science, culture, education and in mass organization, for example, in socialism.

We now observe how, with the rapid flowering of intellectual and spiritual forces, various talents and gifts, i.e. development of the external and average man, at the same time, his moral decomposition, rapid from generation to generation, began, the loss by the individual moral forces and the inner moral person. Then with the fall of socialism, i.e. external landmarks of life, confusion began.

People have split into three layers: ardent antitheists (all of them are against Orthodoxy), the second are atheists (indifferent to any religions and religious life, they live contentedly human culture) and third ones, in whom religious life has recently begun to manifest itself among the first and second. Not faith from above, but human religiosity, characteristic of a person of any nationality. This religiosity, as a human property, needs external supports: the earthly religious environment, religious authorities and religious power. At the same time, depending on the character of the person, she either constitutes the environment, or becomes an authority for this environment, or becomes ecclesiastical authority.

Ordination elevates a person to the ecclesiastical authority of “knitting and solving.” A person becomes an authority either by appointment by church authorities, for example, by a rector, or by personal talents, knowledge and skills: natural - cultural and spiritually educational - or false, supernatural, non-ecclesiastical. So, if we talk about the latter, then the example will be those who experienced a false supernatural experience, and then became the founder of sects. For example, Vassarion, or John Bereslavsky (Virgin Center), Yuri Krivonogov (White Brotherhood), Blavatsky (Agni Yoga), etc. And the religious environment is made up of everyone else, depending on where they are inclined by something in their nature: human religiosity , sincerity, intellect, any attachment to authority or power, self-interest, etc. As a result, we can say - no matter how diverse religious life is, it comes down to two mystical practices -

to deification, from the Holy Spirit of a supernatural, grace-filled life (Orthodoxy) or

to demonization (all other religious movements, including Christian ones, based on the individual and fallen nature).

The third direction, which manifested itself with force in the 18th-20th centuries, is the atheization of man, i.e. proud self-realization of the individual or human fallen nature. Both personal self-realization and in the form social movements– science, culture and education, and in the form of the state-forming social system of modern countries. This phenomenon is short-lived and will eventually merge into the second.

Where does beauty come from?

Now, returning to you once again, Gregory, let’s say that the first thing with which we started this conversation did not happen to you. Those. what Saint Theophan speaks about - an extraordinary visitation of grace.

Grace, which breaks bonds in extraordinary action, really changes a person. And even if for some reason she hides from him in his own heart, the trace of her transforming extraordinary action will remain not only in memory, but also in his character changed in a Christian way.

You, after “something very good came out of you,” remained the same and the same as you were before “one fine day something seemed to take possession of you.” Even the headaches returned as if they had never gone away. To this was added a very frank: “It has come,” you write, “despondency and cold.” The saddest thing is that this condition has persisted for 6 years. This is despite the fact that you “pray, ask, turn to priests, search on the Internet, fight, listen to advice.”

Dear Gregory! Your experience is not an experience of grace. It's an experience seduction. The spiritual essence first moved into you, gave you a lot of things to experience that were very similar in appearance to supposedly grace-filled spiritual experiences, and then, now by the action of God, it left you, leaving you not just in a bad, but in a dangerous state for you.

Cases similar to your experience are described in numerous hagiographic literature, especially in patericon, that is, in the chronicles of various monasteries. The experience of being visited by delusion, that is, by a demonic essence, is allowed by God for the stubbornness of a person and for some sin that accompanied you in the first year of your churching.

Such an experience does not go in vain. It leaves behind spiritual damage, which is what you are writing about and asking for help. The sin for which this experience was allowed must be found. The experience of the supernatural was allowed to you a year later, when you began to “search on the Internet, listen to sermons, visit the Orthodox Church, tried to fast and pray. Having realized their sinfulness, they repented.” Somewhere at this time, perhaps after repentance, you were seduced by something in yourself: either by yourself, or by your new life, or by the horizons, plans, and dreams that were opening up for you. This deception you had about yourself was something like this or something similar to what I supposedly listed here.

It must be borne in mind that a charming thought alone will not lead to the instillation of charm. Yours should have been prepared for this internal environment, your soul, your consciousness. It happens that in a state of fallen nature a person becomes painfully infected with the mold of selfish pride or vanity.

Especially “helping” the infusion are such character traits as stubbornness, and hidden conceit, arrogance, and self-confidence in it. Hidden schizophrenic deviations in the psyche are also possible. Chronic headaches can also be a consequence of mental changes, or certain traits and properties in character. But the pain itself, if present for a long time, can have a negative effect on the psyche.

Chronic headaches are often the result of unrealized aspirations. For example, a person expects and demands more from people close to him than they are. He is constantly dissatisfied with them out loud or to himself, he always speaks to them out of reproach, without realizing it to himself. At the same time, he seeks perfection for himself, but just as he constantly scolds others, he also criticizes himself, reproaches himself to the point of self-criticism. Full of inferiority complexes and guilt. Because of this, he walks in constant tension and fear towards people and worries about himself. Does not know the fear of God or knows nothing about it at all.

If in such a state you begin to listen to sermons, try to fast, and pray, then in search of the joy of self-fulfillment you can compensatory imagine something about yourself. Demons, sensing this need for self-realization and self-justification, will enter and increase claims to a delightful state.

And the person will be happy, not suspecting what is wrong with him and with whom his games began. Having played enough, they will leave a person to self-torture, to constant regret that everything has happened and passed, regret to the point of despondency. What does it mean - having played enough? This means that it has spoiled a person in his natural experiences, in relationships with himself, with people around him and with God, spoiling him to unnatural, and to some extent, independently insurmountable states.

Such people lose the ability to live and be in way of life. They are his way of life, they won’t recognize. And if someone treats them well and thereby invites them into a normal relationship, they respond by swirling in their unnatural movements and experiences, and thereby actively spoil the entire structure for their part, not allowing a normal relationship to even begin. As a result, they run away from the way of life under any invented pretext and no longer want to return, avoiding the people of the way of life. For the same reason they don’t go to Church. And if they come, they will stand at the back of the head and the back of the head and leave. Today there are many not only adults, but also equally capricious and nervous children and babies. Outside the Church, naturally, but within the Church itself there are many not only children, but also adults. Demons, if they continue to graze a person, then having damaged them to the point of “coldness” in the soul, “joylessness, as if abandoned by God,” they will still keep watch in order to bring them to despair. Apparently this is what is happening to you.

What to do now?

What to do now? If there is anything in what I have written that you have learned about yourself, repent of it.
And know that in confession, after the priest’s permissive words, the Lord is like an abyss of mercy and endless love and forgiveness - I forgave you and blotted out and whitened everything that you had done and experienced, and now confessed.

I am writing about this especially because unsettled people tend not to trust the sacrament. They hear their tormented experiences, arguments and conclusions louder than the sacrament. They easily return to them, sometimes immediately after confession, and again, carried away by them, begin to live the same things and everything about the same things, i.e. as the holy fathers say, remaining true to yourself and your “wet experiences.”

You remember that after confession of sins, there is no longer anything that can accuse you anywhere.
Moreover, it should not be in your memory or in your consciousness.
You can live without looking back. Live forward to be with God by the commandments of God.

Love your neighbors, because in this love God is with you. And love yourself, your morality, because in it you were created and constructed by God and in the image of God.

To strengthen yourself in your new life after repentance, start reading the 14th chapter of the Gospel of John once every three days, and at first, every day. Make this your rule for at least the next year.

To gradually master church life in the proper order, read my answers to the questions:
No. 12517 – was not at the evening service,
12812 - I am a heretic,
12828 – why God is punishing me,
12234 – or I don’t understand the word love (calling grace),
12973 – my mother and I are Tatars.
And then, if you have enough strength, then No. 14216 - how to grow from dad to father.

God willing, everything will work out for you.

Peace be with you. Archpriest Anatoly Garmaev

10.01.18 Wed 20:35 - Anonymous

Anything is possible, I don't dispute it

Anything is possible, I don't dispute it. Maybe a visit, maybe an admission.
I miss the state, but I don’t strive and I understand that we live not by feelings, but by faith.
I just want to be pleasing to God, but without God I can’t do anything, that’s why I have sorrow.

Because of this, Seraphim of Sarov knelt on a stone for a thousand days and nights. Silouan of Athos writes about something similar. After I turned to God with repentance, I changed dramatically. If I stopped drinking, smoking, swearing, removed all dirty (at that time in my opinion) music, threw out everything related to horoscopes, gave up dishonest earnings, began to read only Christian literature (Isaac the Syrian, Theophan the Recluse, Paisius the Svyatogorets, Ignatius Brianchaninov, Philokalia...).

Was it really not from God? Is there really nothing but beauty all around?
Moreover, I see not angels, but my sins.
Sorry, I didn't want to disturb anyone, it was necessity. But the fact of the matter is that in the first 2-3 years, Grace is so strong that it drives away all inclinations to sin.

“Wasn’t it really from God? Is there really nothing but beauty all around? Moreover, I see not angels, but my sins.”
- Go to Father Anatoly’s community (in Volgograd), live there for a little while, at least a month.
And everything will become clear what happened - maybe a visit.

Here is a wonderful ascetic, Elder Sophrony (Sakharov), was the confessor of the Athonite Greek monastery of St. Paul of Xiropotamia for two whole years. He lived in a cave 3-4 km from the monastery. When it rained, there was water in the cave, flowing from everywhere, he hung a sheet of tin above him in the cave so as not to be completely wet. And that’s where the Greek monks went to him for confession. They respected him very much, seeing his holy life and the gifts of the Holy Spirit on him. And in those days (1930s) on the Holy Mountain there were many simpleton monks, overshadowed by the Grace of the Holy Spirit, and often seeing the uncreated light. But in their simplicity, they did not know this, which protected them from pride and vanity.

So, Elder Sophrony (Sakharov) shares this spiritual technique:
- If God does not reveal (with accuracy) what happened to the spiritual child: visitation or permission. So I say this: “Repent, this was not permission from God.”
And if the monk immediately repented in simplicity and tried to forget and discard this memory, then this is a GOOD SIGN. For those who are seduced usually firmly stand their ground, saying that there was a visitation from God!

So since they responded and were not indignant, and quite calmly, then there is a good chance that there was a visit. But it’s better to undergo an “offline diagnosis”, plunging into the life of the community. In the closed space of the community, everything secret will come out quite soon.

And, of course, it is important to find out what happened and what is now. Treatment varies significantly...
Sorry!

11.01.18 Thu 22:41 - Anonymous

Insanity - I didn’t have such thoughts (in the primitive sense), sorry!
By the way, maybe you don’t know, a very good book was published in 2015 "Birds of the Sky" Simeon of Athos, 2 volumes. This is the diary of Monk Simon, and a very wonderful diary. You can also buy or download it online.

01/12/18 Fri 23:33 - Anonymous

Simeon of Athos.

Thank you, I will definitely find this book. Silouan of Athos has another interesting book, “Why We Are Not Gods.” And about mental disorders I contacted Fr. Anatoly. But that's not the point. Once upon a time God showed me His love and now without this love I am nobody and nothing. I seek God as He is my life. It’s like you’re thirsty and there’s water in front of you, and you see it, but it’s still drawn in the picture. Well, something like that. So I pester everyone, what if someone shares their experience that was not depicted. Thank you for everything, you kind person. May God bless you and your ministry.

02/12/18 Mon 12:50 - Priest Sergius

Sorry, I'm interfering.

From the correspondence we managed to understand only one thing - they are trying to explain to the person that what happened to him was wonderful. And the person is trying to prove that it was a real miracle. Did I understand correctly?

If I understand correctly, I will not agree with either the person who defends his point of view, or with those who are trying to prove the opposite. Visits, no matter who they come from, are real, and a person experiences this state quite realistically. Another person does not see this reality that a person has experienced, so he tries to explain it as he understands. Often this is not what actually happened. The difference is in the little things, but it's not the same. Therefore, a person tries to prove his point. Both are wrong, because in proving something, both are moving away from reality, because they need to come up with an argument to justify their point of view.

I also had a “visit”, after which I became so insignificant that I don’t know what to do now. There was no awareness of the forgiveness of sins, but there was an awareness of my unworthiness so much that my life seemed to continue only by the grace of God. It feels like they crushed you, but left you to live. There was another experience that I was embarrassed to express out loud, but St. Silouan of Athos revealed it to me when I read his life and his sayings. “When a person is in the Holy Spirit, he loves everyone, he has no enemies,” I experienced this love, of course, as much as I could perceive it. I know her now, and that has kept me going over the years. Now more than 20 years have passed since that event, but it still warms me and does not allow me to weaken.

So, my advice to you is, don’t ask anyone what it was? Nobody will tell you this. Continue to stubbornly seek God the Father, but do not expect His visit, otherwise He may come. I hope you understand who. You must look for Him in your heart, when your heart is open to help those near and far. Try not to be alone, even when you are alone, at this moment be with God, or at least before Him, thinking, for example, about the Gospel stories. Do not forget about cleansing your heart at Confession so that there are no doubts, envy, anger, etc. in it. And do not forget about the fulfillment of the New Testament. Then you will understand everything yourself.

04/16/18 Mon 21:58 - Anonymous

Invoking Grace

Hello! I read Father Anatoly Garmaev’s answer to your cry from the heart, and I was very upset, that’s why I’m writing. I just can't remain silent. I will not give examples of quotes from St. Feofana, I’ll just say that I understand you very much, I myself experienced the touch of God, being an absolutely unbelieving person at the age of 19. And for almost 20 years after that I was in the state that you describe (despondency, hardship, etc.) And always, no matter how difficult it was, I remembered WHAT the Lord once gave in my heart. And this gave me strength to go and go...

You know, I (unfortunately) also had to go through communication with the “young age”... Its main feature is categorical judgments. I won't stop here either. And you know, when after 20 years of “ordeal” the Lord returned everything to me in EXCESS, then, having crushed my whole being into “I am dust and ashes,” I regretted only one thing: LACK OF FAITH and doubt in the promises of God during these years of trials. I felt so SHAMED, impossibly ashamed before the Merciful God, that there were moments of despondency, doubt, trust in the one who said: “This is all from the evil one”... That this trust in a clergyman outweighed my faith in God for several years, who called me, sinful, from simple non-existence, from dirt, from petrified life... And if I knew what the Lord was preparing for me, if I firmly believed in Him, then it would have happened earlier - now I know this for sure.

I don’t know your name (I even started praying for you when I read the correspondence), but I have one piece of advice for you. Always remember the phrase that Fr. John (Krestyankin) repeated as a mother’s blessing: “God will not do anything bad.”
Second: pray to your Guardian Angel (pray every day, read the akathist to him every day!). He is responsible for you before God. You can’t imagine how qualitatively everything will change when you start constantly calling on him! It will change immediately, believe me.
And lastly: remember that priests are people too, and they can make mistakes, just simple mistakes. Go to church, confess, take communion more often.
And always keep in your heart this touch of God, this Invoking Grace. You will not forget it, it is impossible to forget.
And the fact that you have been allowed a painful, seemingly graceless state is a test of your FAITH. As they say, how much grief a person is given to endure is how much happiness he can contain... Christ is Risen!!!

04/17/18 Tue 22:45 - Anonymous

Hello

Truly Risen! Thank you very much for your message and concern. During this time, I never found a reason why everything happened this way. He burned so much, loved so much, everything was Christian, and then suddenly there was emptiness. I didn’t think, I didn’t ask, nothing.

And today I remembered an incident after your letter, although I also thought about this before, because... tried everything possible. I didn’t do biometrics, but I contacted the bank. I wanted to get a bank card for the convenience of money transfers. Before entering the bank, I turn to God, whether I need it or not. When I opened the door to the bank, my phone rang. It was mine brother. He said he fell off a stool and broke his arm. I didn't get to the bank that day. The fracture was very bad, I had to put a plate in my arm, my brother still walks with it.
But a week or a month passed and I silently went and applied for a Privatbank card. They also gave me a credit card.
A few years later I closed these cards and broke up with the bank, but not for long, about two years.
Recently I again applied for services from the bank and I regret it, I want to pay off the credit card and not even think about it anymore. I don’t know what’s next, I miss God, but it’s as if He hid His face from me. I had communication with God, I knew that He was nearby.

Thank you for everything. Sorry if something is wrong. Christ is risen!

04/18/18 Wed 10:38 - Anonymous

Truly Christ is Risen!

Grigory, yes, there is nothing good in cards and banks, I agree. As a family, we abandoned them, and we don’t need any worldly convenience - such inner freedom has arrived..

Now to your letter. There is one point I will note. I would venture to guess: you go to Orthodox church infrequently, receive communion less than once every three weeks, do not know the annual cycle of church holidays (not with the knowledge of your mind, but with your little legs) go to church for services every Sunday, all twelfth holidays and great ones, if possible . So? Do you know why this assumption is made? A church person, at least one who has been going to church for six years after his conversion to God, will not respond the way you responded to the Easter greeting. And he answers in Church Slavonic: Truly He is Risen!!! This goes without saying, naturally. And you say like a secular person: Christ is Risen.

Gregory, look for God in an Orthodox church (while you can still go to churches, while there are still Orthodox churches where they serve according to the canons and there are no modernist changes, until our churches are Catholicized), appreciate the opportunity every Saturday evening and Sunday at the Liturgy to be at the greatest land of the Last Supper, which our Lord Jesus Christ celebrates! Do not lose the opportunity to take communion; this must be done at least once every three weeks. According to the canons of the Church, a person who has not received communion on more than three Sundays in a row excludes himself from the Body of the Church. And we also need to repent of this - that we have not received communion for more than three Sunday Liturgies in a row. You are looking for God, but He Himself is waiting for you every Sunday at Communion!

If you, having sincerely confessed, take communion regularly, then HOW can you not feel God? We must work now, work with all our might. Grace was given to you in advance seven years ago, just like that. Not by business, but by Love. It was given so that you would now seek God, seek Him where He put it on your heart - in the temple.

“From the days of John the Baptist until now, the Kingdom of Heaven has been in need (it is received with need), and the needy has caught it up” (Gospel of Matthew, 11, 12). And He will answer - answer in the heart.

Not on the Internet, not in philosophical conversations, but in those places where He is present - in the temple, in the hospital, in prison, where people suffer hardships and are waiting for help. Help the homeless, feed the hungry... Especially now, before the Ascension - when the Lord literally walks the earth, when through any person He can Himself test us for our mercy, our faith. I speak from experience - by helping our neighbor who is suffering hardships (no matter who he is - a Muslim, an atheist, or anyone) - we heal the wounds of the Gospel poor man who has fallen into the hands of robbers. And the Lord literally “washes” our heart with His Grace. While you are alive, you have the opportunity to do this.

You yearn for God - this means your soul is alive - now DO AND BELIEVE. Have you heard the audio “The Vision-Dream of a Woman in 1994 (Revelation N)” in five parts? If you haven't heard, here's a short summary.
“In 1994, one woman, a Muscovite (who decided not to identify herself), was shown a dream-vision in which she lived her life in one night. future life. Overnight she became a believer, an Orthodox Christian. The Lord showed her what probably awaits us all in the near future. In particular, about the third world war, about an asteroid on America, about climate change in the world, about the real Resurrection of Elder Seraphim of Sarov, about the flood in St. Petersburg, about the flooding of the metro in Moscow, and about much more. Her vision coincides with the prophecy of many saints who lived in the past.
The recording was made public at the beginning of 2013, with the blessing of Archimandrite Seraphim (Stoyanov)"
.

Listen to the 4th part - about the Last Judgment. This woman was shown the Last Judgment - how all earthly generations stood in childbirth at the last Judgment. Why exactly this is what I recommend listening to - it is clearly conveyed to us to the point of piercingness - WHAT our deeds will intercede for us before God at the last Judgment, when we will no longer be able to do ANYTHING - neither justify ourselves, nor escape from this...

My letter is big, but it’s so easy on my heart)). CHRIST IS RISEN!!!

Number of entries: 16441

Good afternoon Some time ago I dreamed about my mother's death several times, after the last similar dream Mom died (a month ago). Now I dream that my husband is dying (I have dreamed about this twice already). I also often dream that my mother seems to have come to life. I don't understand anything. Help me understand what this is all about. What should I do??? I'm very worried about my husband.

Maria

Dear Mary, do not be afraid of dreams, but trust all your fears to the Lord God in prayer. Since you are worried about your husband, pray especially for him, okay holy gospel read. God bless you!

Priest Sergius Osipov

Hello, priests! I want to thank you, and in your person the entire Orthodox priesthood, for your invaluable help and blessed work! Glory to the Lord for his care for people with your hands and words! Such a question. In my prayer book there is a sequence on the departure of the soul from the body, consisting of one canon. It is signed that it is read by the laity if there is no priest. I just can’t quite figure out whether this is a canon about a single deceased person or another canon that must be read immediately after the death of a person? I would like to read it for the repose of my father’s soul. Is it possible? And one more thing. Is it possible to wipe the face on icons with a cloth or do you just need to carefully blow off the dust from it? I was told that I couldn’t touch my face. This is true? Save me, Lord!

Tatiana

Hello, Tatyana. The canon of the one-dead and the succession according to the exodus of the soul are different successions. You can read it. You can wipe the icons without touching (or kissing) the face, so as not to damage it, and not for sacramental reasons. God help you!

Priest Sergius Osipov

Hello. I am interested in the following question: Is it possible to pray for the health and well-being of unbaptized children and grandchildren? (the son-in-law does not consent to the baptism of the child) And will the Lord hear such prayers?

Natalia

Hello, Natalya. Of course, you can and should pray, both at home and in church. Only in church remember them yourself during the reading of the hours (then a proskomedia is performed before the liturgy); only baptized people can be written in notes. God bless you.

Priest Sergius Osipov

Hello, priests. Is it possible to listen to the audiobook of Abbot N Hidden Athos? I liked it when I listened to it once, and Abbot N is Abbot Efrem Vinogradov, he also wrote a book about why they want to save us. I liked both books. Is it possible to read and listen to these books?

Catherine

Yes, Ekaterina, you can. God help.

Priest Sergius Osipov

Hello! Thank you very much to Priest Sergius Osipov for answering my question about “... is it possible to change the name given to me at baptism if no one remembers or knows it...” But the fact is that when my wife goes to church, to the temple and writes notes with names, then my name is crossed out by the grandmothers who accept these notes, citing the fact that my name is not on the lists of Orthodox Christians (my name is Eduard) and this has already happened in no church and no temple. Believe me, I don’t tell you I’m complaining, I just want to know what to do in such situations? Is it possible to film your answer on your phone and show it in churches and temples if my name is crossed out again? Or change the name of your heavenly patron? Excuse me if you are annoying and illiterate in church affairs. Thank you very much in advance.

Edward

Hello, Eduard. This issue will be resolved with the blessing of the priest of the temple where the candle makers so zealously check the notes. The wife can approach him, but it is better, of course, for you to defend your saint yourself :) God bless you.

Priest Sergius Osipov

Hello. My child is 1.9. Baptized with Love. That was the name of her father’s mother. He left me about 5 months ago and I want to change the child’s first and last name. Name for Vitaly. There are no patron saints with that name among the female saints, as I understand from the Internet. What even seems significant to me: let her be love in baptism, I loved her father, even though we lived in fornication, he left the family first and even divorced. If I had immediately called her Vitalia, she would still have been baptized by a different name, I understand correctly, since the saints feminine no with that name? I’m changing her first and last name because it’s hard to bear being constantly reminded of the name and memory of this person. Will I sin a lot if I make such a change or do I have the right to slightly alleviate my grief at the loss of support and hope for family happiness with such a step? After all, that's all I can do. I’ll say right away that I don’t believe in God’s mercy and I can’t wait for relief through prayers and cultivating faith in myself, it’s too hard to be left alone. I need more effective and real support.

Maria

Mary, the name given at baptism does not change. If you decide to change your child’s “worldly” name, think about whether it will be difficult for her to live with the somewhat unexpected, unusual name for a girl, Vitaly. God bless you.

Priest Sergius Osipov

Good afternoon Father, I have three godsons - Alexander (born January 5), Sergius (January 12) and Pavel (July 29). Which saints are considered their heavenly patrons and when is it correct to congratulate them on Angel’s Day?

Tatiana

Dear Tatyana, in order not to guess and make mistakes, it is better to ask your parents which saint is written on the baptismal certificate. It will be possible to determine the day of the angel by the name of the saint by turning, for example, to the website days.pravoslavie.ru. You can congratulate in any words that fit your heart, and on Angel’s Day it’s good to take them (if the godchildren are still children, of course) to church for communion. God bless you.

Priest Sergius Osipov

Good afternoon, a question for Sergei Osipov. I have a small child, her father, my partner for two years, left me in the summer of this year. The feeling of tenderness and admiration for the child has disappeared. I live only with a sense of duty, that I do not honor life and that it is a great burden to her. The father is not against taking her away, according to his words. I myself feel that in his family, where he left me and got divorced, his daughter will be calmer in every sense. What is more sinful - to give it to him (I myself am ready to go to the monastery, I have no debt to the child here, I am already 40, we have several monasteries in the city, I have already written to the abbess, to seek humility and faith) or to keep it with me on principle (the principle, i.e. that it is generally accepted that children with mothers are better off), tormenting her with his inescapable despondency (I can’t fight it, I’m tired). Thank you.

Maria

Dear Mary, do not choose the lesser of two evils. “Inescapable sadness” is called depression. The doctor will help you cure it. Then you won’t have to choose from unacceptable options. God help you!

Priest Sergius Osipov

Hello, Father Alexander. If I took the books of Mother Photinia to the temple, and then let them do what they want with them, did I do the right thing? It happens with us that people bring icons and books to the temple, and others take them.

Catherine

Hello, Ekaterina. When something useful, but no longer needed, is brought to the temple so that others who want or need it can use this thing, then this is good. But sectarian literature must be immediately destroyed so that no one catches the infection. Imagine that someone will take the book you left and read it with confidence, because he took it from the temple, which means it is permissible to read. This person, if he turns out to be ignorant of Orthodox doctrine, will be harmed, and the sin will be on you. Correct what you have done, if it is not too late, and be sure to confess.

Priest Alexander Beloslyudov

Hello, fathers! Help me understand this issue. I believe that God is not subject to change. I also believe that Jesus Christ, our Savior, ascended to heaven along with human nature (since in Jesus Christ both natures were united inseparably and forever), and thus human nature through Jesus Christ became part of the Holy Trinity. It seems to my unenlightened mind that a change did occur in God the moment Jesus ascended into heaven. Help me find the error in such reasoning. God bless you!

Paul

Hello, Pavel. The Chalcedonian oros defines the image of the union of natures, Divine and human, in Christ with four negations (apophatically): unfused, untransformed, inseparable, inseparable. You paid attention only to the last two, “inseparably and inseparably.” Now notice that these are the third and fourth definitions, and the first and second point to the "unconfluence and immutability" of the natures in Christ. Neither human nature acquired anything unusual for it, nor did the Divine nature undergo any changes. Humanity was “hypostatized” - perceived by the Son as the second Person of the Holy Trinity, and not perceived into the single nature (essence) of the Divinity, the One and indivisible Holy Trinity. Otherwise, both God and man would have changed, but this did not happen. And even in the Hypostasis of the Son, His Personality, there was no transformation into something in between Divinity and humanity. Oros describes the properties of the compound apophatically, because nothing cataphatic can be said about it without distorting the truth. We do not even see our own created nature, we see only the skin, so how can we judge the nature of the Divine? Therefore, the Holy Council simply cuts off everything that distorts the truth, but does not formulate the truth itself, for lack of the possibility of logical understanding of this issue. The mystery of God's existence cannot be comprehended by the mind, but can be known by experience. As the fathers expressed it, God is known by the power of life. The mystery of intradivine existence is learned in the Kingdom of God, about which Christ said that it is within us. The entrance is narrow and not many people find it. But those who entered saw a truth there that cannot be expressed in human language. The experience cannot be expressed in words. The experience can only be repeated. So that those seeking to know God through their own experience would not get lost, the fathers set guidelines for them. These guidelines are dogmatic definitions and ascetic teachings. They are in our coordinate system, but by using them and forcing ourselves to an appropriate way of thinking, a way of life, we can gain experience that corresponds to our structure, about God, about Providence, about Love. In the primal Church, only those who knew God in the cell of their hearts were called theologians, and not those who spoke well about God. I think that you are quite capable and will find it useful to read the works of Rev. Isaac the Syrian: and “Words of Asceticism”, and “On Divine Mysteries”.

Priest Alexander Beloslyudov

Hello, Father. I recently came across this video testimony (...), and as a believer, I Orthodox man, this came as a shock. I know that this evidence cannot be trusted, but still I wanted to know if this evidence is true? God bless you!

Dmitry

Hello, Dmitry. Most likely, this girl is speaking sincerely. But what bothers you? In Catholicism, the delirium of a sick imagination, demonic delusion and outright demonic possession have long been elevated to the rank of revelation. The content of such “revelations” is not a reflection of objective reality, but reflects only what was shown to the unfortunate woman by demons. She tells the truth, what she saw, what she heard, that’s what she says. I just mixed up the source. But she has no means of distinguishing a demon from an Angel. In Orthodoxy, this phenomenon has been known for a long time and has its own name - prelest. I advise you, for your personal spiritual safety, never, under any circumstances, watch, listen to or discuss anything related to supernatural phenomena and mystical experiences. The Lord gave man after the fall leather vestments to protect him from the direct influence of demons exiled to earth, into the same space as man. But we are curious.... So we strive to dig a hole in these protective vestments. But what enters the gap is not the knowledge of the truth, but the knowledge of demons. The goal of these subjects is death.

Priest Alexander Beloslyudov

Question to priest Alexander Beloslyudov. Father! Tell me please. I am married, my husband is not a church member. I miss communication. And this has been the case since the very beginning of our relationship. There are few general topics for conversation. I have few friends, and I am always very happy when I find like-minded people. This happens to all my friends, regardless of gender. In this regard, the question is: what to do if a congenial person with whom you develop a warm relationship is male? Should we stop communicating just because he is a man? Or is it still possible to be friends? And if so, how can we understand where the acceptable boundaries of this friendship are? God bless you!

Olga

Hello, Olga. It is difficult to draw a clear line in communication. In actions, yes, it is possible. While we are drinking tea, this is normal, but when we are already hugging, then this is fornication. But pay attention to whether voluptuous thoughts are creeping into the conversation itself. It seems to me that we should pay attention to the words that the Apostle Paul addressed to wives with unbelieving husbands: “How do you know, wife, whether you will not save your husband?” Probably, we should not run away from our husband in search of communication, but look for points of contact from which we can, drop by drop, lay the preconditions for spiritual interest. I can’t tell you specifically what to do, you have to find it yourself. Just think in this direction. And friends are a good thing until you begin to value them more than your husband. God help you.

Priest Alexander Beloslyudov

Please resolve my confusion. What is the degree of obedience of a parishioner to a confessor? 7 years ago I asked for a blessing to buy a car, but I never received it. Father said: “You will die.” I studied and got my license. But since I don’t have a car, I didn’t start driving. Now I understand that a car is necessary for trips to the country, to take, bring building materials, things, crops, to go order something, to transport pets. Until now, I traveled by train (it’s really hard to carry 20 kg) or with my parents by car. But the parents will soon grow old. I'm single. I was afraid to buy a car, but I understand that without a car it’s difficult to manage a dacha. Sorry for asking this question.

Evgenia

Hello, Evgenia. The priest has no moral right to give orders. Obedience in the proper sense is possible only in the relationship between a student and an elder. This phenomenon monastic life. This word also refers to the relationship between a subordinate and a superior. In a broad sense, following Christ is like obedience to God. In the relationship between a layman and a parish priest, this form is unacceptable in principle. In spiritual matters, a priest, if he has sufficient experience and common sense, can give useful advice, and you can implement them or not, according to your own reasoning. If you see that the advice is useful and does not contradict the teachings of the fathers, follow it. If you see that the advice contains passion (power, vanity, pride), or it contradicts the teachings of the fathers, then you do not need to follow it. And everything that concerns private life, relationships with people, work, everyday life has nothing to do with the priest. If he gets into these topics, then this is a warning sign. Maybe in all other respects the priest is wonderful. Then don’t tempt him anymore, don’t ask questions related to your everyday life. Take blessings only for spiritual things. For prayer, fasting, any good undertaking. But you make the decision. You, and only you, are responsible before God for your decisions, actions and intentions. If you need a car, take it. Anyone can get killed. Everything is in God's hands. However, since you do not have practice, be sure to take special safe driving courses. Learn useful skills that are worth your time and money. God help you.

Priest Alexander Beloslyudov

Hello, Father Alexander. Did the Apostle Paul lose his freedom when the Lord appeared to him and asked why he was persecuting Him? And if sometimes I want the Lord to appear to me Himself and show me the demons, or to put me in hell for at least 5 minutes so that I know what it’s like to be in hell, can I ask Him for this? Venerable Seraphim Sarovsky also saw demons.

Catherine

Hello again, Ekaterina. Saul was always a sincere believer in One God. He persecuted Christians out of ignorance. When the light shone on his path, and the Divine voice addressed him, he immediately fell to the ground, bowing before God. Having learned that it was Christ, he immediately cast aside his previous conviction and freely surrendered himself to the Lord: what do you tell me to do? Remember how the Virgin answered the Angel: behold the handmaid of the Lord, let it be done to me according to your word. How the apostles abandoned their nets and followed Christ at His call. There is no loss of freedom here, there is choice. And the choice is obvious. The Jewish leaders, after all, also did not doubt the Divinity of Christ after the resurrection of Lazarus, but did not recognize Him, but became embittered. They made a different choice. And Judas made a different choice. Asking God to show demons and hell is foolish. The Lord protected us from the perception of spiritual beings for our own safety. If your child asks you to let him run barefoot in the snow or eat an icicle, will you allow him? Isaac the Syrian said that in order to see Heaven and the Lord, you must force yourself to enter your heart. The Kingdom of God is within you. And Angels, and demons, and hell are there too. Be sure to read the “Sermon on the Sensual and Spiritual Vision of Spirits”, St. Ignatius Brianchaninov. Get comprehensive and sound information about this issue.

Priest Alexander Beloslyudov

Hello, Father Alexander. In the letters of abbot Nikon Vorobyov about suicide it is written that anyone, even on purpose, in order to scare other people, climbs into a noose, the demons will strangle him against his will. How can they do this if they are spirits, and without God’s permission they cannot do anything with a person? And if I had thoughts that it was better to die than to live with sorrows, was it from demons? Is there an audiobook on the Internet “Great Russian Elders” by Abbot Aristarkh Lokhanov, and is it possible to listen to the soulful teachings of Abba Dorotheus in audio format?

Catherine

The answer to the first question, Catherine, you will find in the same “Word” of St. Ignatius. The suicide gives himself over to the demons, so they gain power over him. But even in this case, they remain an instrument of God’s Providence. The books you are looking for are here: http://predanie.ru/audio/izdanija-predanie-ru/velikie-russkie-starcy/ - these are the “Elders”, and this is Abba Dorotheus: http://predanie.ru/audio/jitija_i_tvorenija_svjatih /prepodobnii-avva-dorofei/.

Priest Alexander Beloslyudov

Can a priest serve two liturgies in one astronomical day? One in the morning, as usual, and the second in the evening, after Vespers and Matins, on the next church day?

Elena

Hello, Elena. The day is counted from midnight to midnight. There are instructions about this in the “Teacher’s Certificate” placed in the Service Book. And every priest uses the Missal. During the day, only one celebration of the liturgy is possible. Once a day on one throne, by one priest. Here is an extract from the "Handbook of the Clergyman": " Ancient Rule determines the time of execution Divine Liturgy the third hour, according to our calculation the ninth. It can be performed earlier or later, as circumstances require, but not after noon and not before dawn. The only exceptions are some days when the liturgy is celebrated “porana” or combined with the evening service. This is the day of Holy Easter, the days of Holy Pentecost for the Liturgy of the Presanctified Gifts, the days of the eve of the Nativity of Christ and Epiphany, as well as the days of Great Saturday and Pentecost. A priest cannot perform more than one liturgy on one day. The participation of a priest who has already served on the same day in the conciliar celebration of another liturgy is unacceptable. On one altar on one day, only one liturgy can be performed due to the unity of the sacrifice of the cross made by the Lord Jesus Christ." Although the liturgy is celebrated several times a year in conjunction with Vespers, it is not celebrated at the usual time for Vespers, not in the evening, but in the morning, so that the liturgy is celebrated during daylight hours. The Liturgy of the Presanctified Gifts does not contain the Eucharist, but is simply Communion, and therefore can be celebrated in the morning. evening time. Let me remind you that in Great Lent the Eucharist (the complete liturgy of Basil the Great and John Chrysostom with the consecration of the Holy Gifts) is celebrated only on Saturday, Sunday, the Annunciation and Holy Thursday.

Priest Alexander Beloslyudov

Father, tell me, how does the church feel about circumcision among Orthodox Christians? Medicine talks about the hygienic benefits of this procedure, but from the point of view of religion, if a person abstains, wouldn’t this be a kind of help for him in this? Or is it self-harm? Sorry for the pun.

Dmitry

Hello, Dmitry. Circumcision has no effect on lust, and therefore does not help abstinence. Hygiene should be maintained with water and soap, equally for circumcised and uncircumcised. So this is not an argument either. The only medical indication for circumcision is the inability to have sexual intercourse due to the anatomy of the genital organ.

Priest Alexander Beloslyudov