Anna Akhmatova - Clasped her hands under a dark veil: Verse. The poem “Clenched my hands under a dark veil...” by A.A

I’m sitting here writing an interpretation of this poem. I don't understand what to write about. Do you really like it? I don't see the point in it. Maybe it's because I'm forced to do it. Who likes being forced? Or maybe it’s the aunt who writes dumbly. In any case, I don't understand her. Sorry if something is wrong. I shouldn’t have written to you, because you have a paid account, and this already means a lot... well, at least that you don’t care about people like me.
Thank you

Analyzing is always difficult.

It's probably never been read aloud to you...

Excellent verse, simply wonderful! In him whole story separation is visible... what’s unclear???

A somewhat distorted musical version of this poem:
http://ru.youtube.com/watch?v=CW2qyhGuVvQ

And in my opinion it’s very cool. It’s like that interesting attitude hero to heroine. He believes that she does not want to see him next to her, but nevertheless worries about her.

That's right, I agree with your statement!

in fact, he just doesn’t care about her feelings. in response to the admission that she can’t live without him, he just pretends to be worried about her... very sad verse

This is just a magnificent poem; out of all the work Akhmatova covered at school, I only remembered this.

brilliant poem! I understand it this way: the girl “became bitchy”, for which she paid...

I really love this poem!
“Don’t stand in the wind” - that’s how I feel - because he doesn’t believe her anymore, that “if you leave, I’ll die.” For some reason I remembered from the film “The Hussar Ballad”: “- Do you want the truth? - No, I don’t play this game anymore. I don’t want the truth or lies.”

But in fact, he still loves her. Just very tired.

During the evacuation, Akhmatova and Ranevskaya often walked around Tashkent together. “We wandered around the market, around the old city,” Ranevskaya recalled. Children ran after me and shouted in unison: “Mulya, don’t irritate me.” This was very annoying, it prevented me from listening to Anna Andreevna. In addition, I acutely hated the role that brought popularity. I told Akhmatova about this. “Don’t be upset, each of us has our own Mylya!” “I clenched my hands under a dark veil” - these are my “Mules,” said Anna Andreevna.”

the poem is actually brilliant.. about love and the severity of parting.. about how absurd careless word can kill trust and feelings.. when I read it for the first time, a chill went down my spine.. you can’t even understand it, you have to feel it

I read this poem before, but did not think about its depth..
and now, finding myself in a similar situation to the heroine, I felt it and let it pass through me - I burst into tears

I really liked it)

but it seems to me that starting with the words “she clasped her hands under a dark veil” this means he has already died and she remembers what was the impetus for this accident, for such a separation

There is some kind of understatement in this poem. He is so indifferent to the heroine, and she is to him, as they say, with all her soul. I wanted the best, but it turned out...

Great poem

This poem talks about how the girl was just playing... she didn’t want it, but he just couldn’t stand it and left, she realized it too late... he still loves her “don’t stand in the wind,” but he can’t be brought back. .. I really like this poem... I know it by heart...

I would compare this poem to photography. photography in motion. Everything is clearly visible and you can even examine the details, understand the presence of a conflict and the drama of the situation. But, just like looking at a photograph, for example, of a girl looking detachedly out the window, one can only guess about the reasons for her thoughtfulness, or maybe sadness... Also in the work in question, someone believes that the last phrase thrown is “don’t stand in the wind " - dictated by concern for the still loved one, some considered it a period, others an ellipsis. What is certain is that this is not a dot above the “i”. This is precisely why I don’t really like so-called “multi-layered works”, for which I am often criticized. Everyone says that the author wanted to tell us in his work... What did the author want to say? The author no longer exists, and everyone decides for themselves what the author wanted to tell us, or rather invents. Someone reads critics - enlightened interpreters and translators from the divine to the philistine. Although they link the lines of the work with the facts of the biography, they, nevertheless, also make assumptions regarding the author’s intention. As a result, we get the very problem that haunts almost everyone, and which is captured in this photograph in verse - she said, he answered. He understood the meaning of what she said in his own way, turned around, left... The meaning of his answer is a mystery to her, and to the reader too. What is this? Care or indifference? Desire to leave uncertainty? For what? To come back or to make you go dark in revenge? There are no answers. And for the reader’s soul, rushing about in search of an answer, who may have found himself in a similar situation in his life, suffered, did not know what to do, how to understand the reasons for the tragedy unfolding in his life, such uncertainty, understatement is painful and unpleasant. In essence, it forces you to repeat your personal experience in miniature, without receiving the answers that the reader is often looking for in works, because if you think about it, few people read lyrics solely for the beauty of the style or just to see the picture (description of the situation), in fact, from quite Everyday life. It is this repeated experience that explains the fact that sensitive people can even burst into tears when reading it, they are so “touched to the quick.”

In conclusion, I would like to summarize)))) Drawing conclusions is always very difficult. It is much easier to describe the situation in a comprehensive, elegant style, and put a long ellipsis at the end, inviting you to draw your own conclusions. If the author's goal is to start a vengeful process in the reader's head, perhaps this is the best way. But this goal is unlikely to be achievable if the reader has not experienced something similar to what is described in his life. In this case, the reader will simply skim the text with his eyes and pass by; the text will not evoke a response in his soul. If the reader is close to the described experiences, he probably himself has repeatedly thought about the questions that arise, but did not find answers, conducting a long and painful monologue with himself. And, in this case, after reading the work, the reader first relives his little tragedy, then again finds no answers and falls into the void... Perhaps you will tell me that there are no universal and correct answers, so what are they for? To this I will answer that there must certainly be an answer, a conclusion, a crystallization of the thought embedded in the work. The reader can agree with this conclusion or, on the contrary, disagree, present his own arguments and, thus, come to the only truth acceptable to himself, find his answer, emerging from the labyrinth of events and facts in which he has been wandering for a long time.
So I, in my written, “special” opinion, reached the moment when it is necessary to draw a conclusion from everything that was said, the expressed opinion crystallized in one phrase. And I will tell you again that it is difficult. I will say that it’s easier to put a long ellipsis after the word “wanders”, sort of beautiful, philosophical))))) So that when you come to this moment my reader, left the table a little hungry)))
So, IMHO - literary works, in which the author, having spread his thoughts throughout the entire work, does not give himself the trouble to express at the end own opinion, attitudes, for me in some abstract sense of the word, are faceless, since they do not contain the most important part of the author who created them - his attitude to the situation, to the issues presented in his work, his personal opinion. Having cut out a picture from life from paper and words, even if it was cut out very beautifully, the author did not endow the idea with a soul. Therefore, having thought about why some works, despite the majesty and significance attributed to them, are categorically uninteresting, I found the only answer - because they are empty, despite the beauty of their style.

I remember from school it was with him that my love for poetry began. The cruel girl, I feel very sorry for her, without even realizing it, she ruined her great feeling for her. He loves her, but he doesn’t have the strength to be there, it’s easier to leave than to stay.

He is a very proud man who cannot get over himself. Yes, she did not understand to the very last point what this man meant to her. She liked it, it flattered her vanity that he was selflessly in love with her. But when I realized that I could lose him, I was horrified by this thought alone and ran after him. I'm afraid that it's too late - it's burned out(((. It's a shame that few modern poets can express such a range of feelings in a few lines. In fact, at least, a big story ran through me when I read this short brilliant poem. BRAVO !

He is not worried about her, but mockingly tells her not to follow him and that it is completely useless to return him. With this phrase he puts an end to their relationship.

Each verse of Anna Andreevna Akhmatova touches the finest strings human soul, although the author does not use many means of expression and figures of speech. “Clenched her hands under a dark veil” proves that the poetess could say quite a lot about the complex in simple words, accessible to everyone. She sincerely believed that the simpler the language material, the more sensual, vibrant, emotional and life-like her poems became. Judge for yourself...

Features of Akhmatova's lyrics. Thematic groups

A. A. Akhmatova proudly called herself a poet; she did not like it when the name “poetess” was applied to her; it seemed to her that this word belittled her dignity. And indeed, her works stand on a par with the works of such grandiose authors as Pushkin, Lermontov, Tyutchev, Blok. As an Acmeist poet, A. A. Akhmatova paid great attention to word and image. Her poetry had few symbols, few figurative means. It’s just that every verb and every definition was selected with special care. Although, of course, Anna Akhmatova paid great attention to women's issues, that is, such topics as love, marriage. There were many poems dedicated to her fellow poets and the topic of creativity. Akhmatova also created several poems about the war. But, of course, the bulk of her poems are about love.

Akhmatova’s poems about love: features of the interpretation of feelings

In almost no poem by Anna Andreevna, love was described as a happy feeling. Yes, she is always strong, bright, but fatal. Moreover, the tragic outcome of events can be dictated by various reasons: inconsistency, jealousy, betrayal, indifference of a partner. Akhmatova spoke about love simply, but at the same time solemnly, without diminishing the importance of this feeling for any person. Often her poems are eventful, in them one can distinguish a unique analysis of the poem “Clenched her hands under a dark veil” confirms this idea.

The masterpiece called “The Gray-Eyed King” can also be classified as love poetry. Here Anna Andreevna talks about adultery. The gray-eyed king - the beloved of the lyrical heroine - dies by accident while hunting. But the poetess slightly hints that the husband of this very heroine had a hand in this death. And the ending of the poem sounds so beautiful, in which a woman looks into the eyes of her daughter, the colors... It would seem that Anna Akhmatova managed to elevate a banal betrayal to a deep poetic feeling.

A classic case of misalliance is depicted by Akhmatov in the poem “You are my letter, dear, don’t crumple.” The heroes of this work are not allowed to be together. After all, she always has to be nothing to him, just a stranger.

“Clenched hands under a dark veil”: theme and idea of ​​the poem

In a broad sense, the theme of the poem is love. But, to be more specific, then we're talking about about breaking up. The idea of ​​the poem is that lovers often do things rashly and without thinking, and then regret it. Akhmatova also says that loved ones sometimes show apparent indifference, while in their souls there is a real storm.

Lyrical plot

The poetess depicts the moment of parting. The heroine who shouted unnecessary and offensive words to her lover, hurries after him up the steps, but, having caught up, she can no longer stop him.

Characteristics of lyrical heroes

Without characterizing the lyrical hero, it is impossible to make a full analysis of the poem. “Clenched Hands Under a Dark Veil” is a work in which two characters appear: a man and a woman. She said stupid things in the heat of the moment and gave him “tart sadness.” He - with visible indifference - tells her: “Don’t stand in the wind.” Akhmatova does not give any other characteristics to her heroes. Their actions and gestures do this for her. This characteristic feature throughout Akhmatova’s poetry: do not talk about feelings directly, but use associations. How does the heroine behave? She clasps her hands under the veil, she runs so that she does not touch the railing, which indicates the greatest tension of mental strength. She doesn't speak, she screams, gasping for breath. And there seems to be no emotion on his face, but his mouth is twisted “painfully,” which indicates that the lyrical hero cares, his indifference and calmness are ostentatious. Suffice it to recall the verse “Song of the Last Meeting”, which also says nothing about feelings, but a seemingly ordinary gesture betrays inner excitement, the deepest experience: the heroine puts a glove on her left hand on her right hand.

An analysis of the poem “Clenched her hands under a dark veil” shows that Akhmatova constructs her poems about love as a lyrical monologue in the first person. Therefore, many mistakenly begin to identify the heroine with the poetess herself. This is not worth doing. Thanks to the first-person narration, the poems become more emotional, confessional and believable. In addition, Anna Akhmatova often uses direct speech as a means of characterizing her characters, which also adds liveliness to her poems.

The poem “Clenched my hands...”, like many other works of Anna Akhmatova, is dedicated to difficult relationships women and men. This essay will provide a detailed analysis of this heartfelt poem. It tells that a woman who offended her lover and decided to break up with him suddenly changed her mind (and that’s what women’s nature is all about, isn’t it?!). She runs after him and asks him to stay, but he just calmly replies, “Don’t stand in the wind.” This leads a woman into a state of despair, depression, she feels incredible pain from parting...

The heroine of the poem is strong and proud woman, she does not cry and does not show her emotions too violently, her intense feelings can only be understood by her clenched hands “under a dark veil”. But when she realizes that she could really lose her loved one, she runs after him, “without touching the railing.” It is worth noting that the heroine’s lover has an equally proud and self-sufficient character; he does not react to her cry that she will die without him, and answers briefly and coldly. The essence of the entire poem is that two people with difficult characters cannot be together, they are hindered by pride, their own principles, etc. They are both close and at the same time different sides an endless abyss... Their confusion is conveyed in the poem not through a long conversation, but through actions and short remarks. But, despite this, the reader can immediately reproduce the complete picture in his imagination.

The poetess was able to convey all the drama and depth of the characters’ experiences in just twelve lines. The poem was created according to all the canons of Russian poetry, it is logically completed, although laconic. The composition of the poem is a dialogue that begins with the question “Why are you pale today?” The last stanza is a culmination and at the same time a denouement; the hero’s answer is calm and at the same time mortally offended by his everyday life. The poem is filled with expressive epithets ( "tart sadness"), metaphors ( "made me drunk with sadness"), antitheses ( "dark" - "pale", "screamed, gasping for breath" - "smiled calmly and creepily"). The meter of the poem is a three-foot anapest.

Undoubtedly, after analyzing “I clasped my hands...” you will want to study essays on other poems by Akhmatova:

• “Requiem”, analysis of Akhmatova’s poem
• “Courage”, analysis of Akhmatova’s poem
• “The Gray-Eyed King,” analysis of Akhmatova’s poem
• "Twenty first. Night. Monday", analysis of Akhmatova’s poem
• “The Garden”, analysis of the poem by Anna Akhmatova
• “Song of the Last Meeting”, analysis of Akhmatova’s poem

It is very difficult to emotionally read the lyric poem “Clenched my hands under a dark veil” by Anna Andreevna Akhmatova. It is imbued with deep drama. The action described in it occurs rapidly. Despite the fact that the work consists of only three quatrains, it tells the whole story of two people in love, namely their separation.

The text of Akhmatova’s poem “Clenched her hands under a dark veil” was written in January 1911. Oddly enough, it was not dedicated to Nikolai Gumilyov, although Anna Andreevna had already been married to him for a year at that moment. Who was this poem dedicated to? This still remains a mystery to many researchers, because the poetess was faithful to her husband throughout her marriage. We will never know the answer to this question. We can only guess. Perhaps Akhmatova herself created the image of this lover and constantly wrote poetry to him. This work tells how two people in love break up after another quarrel. Anna Andreevna does not name the reason for what happened, but with the phrase “she made him drunk with tart sadness” she makes it clear to the reader that it is the girl who is to blame. She regrets what she said and wants her lover back. She runs after him, asks him to come back, shouts that she will die without him, but everything is useless. Thanks to the fact that Akhmatova uses a large number of means of artistic expression, it becomes easier for us to understand how difficult it is for the heroes of the poem at this moment, what feelings they experience.

The poem is compulsory to study at school in literature class in the 11th grade. It, like Akhmatova’s other poem “Song of the Last Meeting,” is assigned to be taught at home. On our website you can read it online in full or download it to any device absolutely free.

She clasped her hands under a dark veil...
“Why are you pale today?”
- Because I am tartly sad
Got him drunk.

How can I forget? He came out staggering
The mouth twisted painfully...
I ran away without touching the railing,
I ran after him to the gate.

Gasping for breath, I shouted: “It’s a joke.
All that has gone before. If you leave, I’ll die.”
Smiled calmly and creepily
And he told me: “Don’t stand in the wind”